Home About Archives RSS Feed

New 'Dumbo' Left This Mom With Dry Eyes

By Rebecca Dravis
iBerkshires Staff
image description
Dumbo is cute, but the movie 'Dumbo' wasn't all that great, our mother/daughter reviewers say.

Welcome back to the first "Mom Review" in a few years! My sidekick Noelle is now a teenager at 13 but she is still willing to share her thoughts on the movies, plays and other family-friendly events we experience to give our Berkshires.com readers a different take on the local cultural scene. First, I'll share my thoughts, and then Noelle will share hers.

When I first heard that Disney was making a live-action version of "Dumbo," I was pretty skeptical. After all, the main characters in this movie are animals, so unless Disney was going to venture into the territory of creepy "talking" real-life creatures, how were they going to pull this one off?

They didn't.

First the good news: Disney WAS able to create a story that didn't require creepy talking real-life animals, thank goodness. Instead, they used very cool special effects to create Dumbo and his mother, and the results of that were pretty spectacular. Dumbo, with his awkward-but-somehow-adorable ears and soulful eyes was as lifelike as possible - and he didn't have to say a word. Neither did his mother, though she had many fewer scenes, nor did the mouse, which appeared only briefly.

Now the bad news: The story was just terrible. Besides the elephant family, the film centers on a family of three: a grieving war hero dad and his two children - who didn't (or maybe couldn't?) breathe much life into the story. There was way too much going on with them: war hero dad returns with one arm to find a wife dead from the flu, no job and a pre-teen daughter he can't relate to because she wants to be scientist and not a circus performer. Had the screenwriters followed any ONE of those storylines, the film could have gone in a more interesting direction. The other actors were lackluster at best, with the possible exception of Danny DeVito, who was as entertaining as always. It pains me to say this, because I've loved Michael Keaton since he was Batman so many years ago, but he was uneven as well. I know it's a Tim Burton-directed piece, but Keaton's character's evil side seemed forced, particularly since it appeared Burton was poking fun at Disney himself and his Disney World. Wanting to kill Mrs. Jumbo just so Dumbo wasn't "distracted" from his flying shows didn't seem deliciously diabolical; it just seemed confusing and mean.

But the worst part for me? I just wasn't touched. To be honest, I can't watch the original "Dumbo" without crying when mama and her baby are separated. And - full disclosure - I cry at most other Disney movies, too. When Simba tries to wake up his dead father? When Rapunzel and her parents are reunited? In "Toy Story 3" when Andy leaves his toys with Bonnie? Total waterworks. I even sniffled before "Dumbo" during the trailer for "Toy Story 4" when it flashes back to that scene in "Toy Story 3." How sappy am I?

In this remake of "Dumbo," thought, it was dry eyes all around. All I could think about was why Mrs. Jumbo's trunk seemed way too long suddenly in an effort to make it wrap around Dumbo.

This "Dumbo" just isn't touching. Maybe it's because watching the exploitation of circus animals isn't heartwarming at all in 2019. Maybe that's not something we want to pass on to today's children - who, by the way, probably won't enjoy this movie very much anyway. The young girl during our showing who was running around during the movie certainly didn't. It's not a cartoon, it's not a musical (though kudos to Disney for working some of the original songs into this film, even in an instrumental fashion so that those of us who remembered the original music recognized it). It's just not FUN. There's a reason it's PG; kids under 8 or so probably will be bored or confused much of time, except when Dumbo is flying, which they will probably think is cool. And they might be scared at the end, which is pretty fiery. Older kids might start to question the whole circus animal morality issue - which Disney ignores in this remake all the way up until the end when Dumbo and his mother are set free in their native India to live out their lives with their wild brethren and the original circus becomes animal-free. (Sorry, spoiler alert.)

Disney has an ambitious slate of releases this year, with the live-action "Aladdin" up next, followed by "Toy Story 4" and then "Frozen 2" this fall. I hope I like those better than "Dumbo." I'm optimistic those will be better. I'll bring the Kleenex.

Noelle says: I didn't really like "Dumbo" either, but I think my mom was a little harsh in her review. I really liked the animation; it seemed pretty real. I agreed that it wasn't very emotional, but I don't cry at movies like my mom does. I just saw "Five Feet Apart" and my friends were all crying but I wasn't. (That was a better movie than "Dumbo," in case you were wondering.) I did like Danny DeVito because he was funny; I don't know him from any other movies but I've seen him in memes on Instagram. I thought the end was very fast-paced, where everything happened very quickly. I didn't think it was scary but I think little kids might be scared by all the fire.

Rebecca Dravis is community editor at iBerkshires.com.

0 Comments
     

Support Local News

We show up at hurricanes, budget meetings, high school games, accidents, fires and community events. We show up at celebrations and tragedies and everything in between. We show up so our readers can learn about pivotal events that affect their communities and their lives.

How important is local news to you? You can support independent, unbiased journalism and help iBerkshires grow for as a little as the cost of a cup of coffee a week.

News Headlines
Kavey Looks to Provide New Perspective in Pittsfield's Ward 5 Bid
New Food & Wellness Vision Planned for Historic Mausert Block
Cats' Bats Go Silent at Ocean State
Pittsfield 12-Year-Olds Earn Walkoff Win in Little League Sectional
Braintree Blanks Pittsfield Babe Ruth 15s at Regional
Pittsfield Babe Ruth 14s Rally to Beat Plymouth at New England Regional
North Adams Has 2 Candidates for Mayor, 15 for City Council
Kavey Announces Run for Pittsfield's Ward 5
Biz Briefs: Tourists Hotel to be Honored at Celebrate the Berkshires Event
Greylock Insurance Agency Producer Earns National Designation


Categories:
Archives:
June 2019 (2)
April 2019 (1)
Tags:
Movie Review Colonial Theatre Barrington Stage Family Jacob's Pillow Tanglewood Musical Family Event Dance Williamstown Theatre Festival Shakespeare & Company
Popular Entries:
The Mom Review: 'Hairspray Jr' Energetic, Thought-Provoking
The Mom Review: 'Servant' An Over-The-Top Farce
The Mom Review: Follow the Yellow Brick Road to Tanglewood
The Mom Review: Oh, The Places We'll Go
The Mom Review: Fairy Tales Come True at Jacob's Pillow
The Mom Review: WTF's Free 'Robin Hood' Is ... Well, Free
The Mom Review: Shakespeare With a Side of Raunch
Say 'Va Bene!' to 'Bleu!' at Jacob's Pillow
The Mom Review: Go See 'Cinderella' Disco
New 'Dumbo' Left This Mom With Dry Eyes
Recent Entries:
'Into the Woods' Is Not Happily Ever After
'Aladdin' Goes Dark, Political and Not As Much Fun
New 'Dumbo' Left This Mom With Dry Eyes
The Mom Review: Fairy Tales Come True at Jacob's Pillow
The Mom Review: Follow the Yellow Brick Road to Tanglewood
The Mom Review: Oh, The Places We'll Go
The Mom Review: 'Hairspray Jr' Energetic, Thought-Provoking
The Mom Review: 'Servant' An Over-The-Top Farce
The Mom Review: WTF's Free 'Robin Hood' Is ... Well, Free
The Mom Review: Shakespeare With a Side of Raunch