Pittsfield Councilors Call For No-Confidence Vote in City Solicitor

By Joe DurwinPittsfield Correspondent
Print Story | Email Story
Updated at 10:06 p.m. on Oct. 4 with comments from Coucilor at Large Melissa Mazzeo.

PITTSFIELD, Mass. — A long growing controversy over a litigation settlement between the city and Spectrum Health Systems over a new methadone clinic has culminated in a petition before the council for a vote of no confidence in City Solicitor Kathleen Degnan.

The petition, put forth by Ward 1 Councilor Christine Yon and Council President Kevin Sherman, challenges the "professional competence" of Degnan as the city's legal representation with regards to her handling of the hotly debated lawsuit with the Worcester-based nonprofit. (See the timeline, pages

Yon, the only one of Pittsfield's 11 city councilors to have been deposed during the process of the case, says comments made by Degnan during court proceedings "provided client attorney information to the Plaintiff Spectrum that was harmful to the city of Pittsfield and harmful to its elected officials."

Included in the City Council packet with the petition is a five-page timeline outlining aspects of the litigation with Spectrum going back to March of this year, when the current city solicitor took over the case, replacing the city's previous legal counsel, attorney Richard Dohoney. The timeline focuses specifically on a series of events surrounding a settlement agreement in June, in which several councilors have previously publicly accused Mayor Daniel Bianchi of misleading the council, a claim the mayor has fervently denied.

Under dispute in the new petition, which will go before the council at its Tuesday, Oct. 9, meeting, are remarks made by Degnan in court on June 26, regarding Councilor Yon's participation in conversations surrounding a planned relocation of the clinic to a residential area adjacent to Berkshire Medical Center in mid-June.

Sherman said the issue is not about whether Spectrum should be here, but arose from the handling of the case.

"Going through the court documents, there was some behavior and judgement and decisions by the solicitor that were very troubling, and some statements that were very harmful to a city councilor specifically, and the city generally," said Sherman. "Which is just unacceptable, in my view."

Sherman said that this was not the first time questions had been raised about the performance of the solicitor since her appointment in January. 

"For the last nine months, there have been other questionable decision making and judgement that we've seen throughout in regards to ordinances and advice on how to proceed on matters."

Sherman said he and Yon had met with the mayor on Sept. 6 to express their concerns and suggest a change in that position. When followup discussion indicated that this was not going to be the case, Sherman said he pressed for subsequent meetings with the mayor and city solicitor.

"Those meetings never materialized," said Sherman. "And at that point, we were a month out, and we had to make a decision."

Bianchi, reached for comment Thursday, did not share the view espoused by the councilors with regards to Degnan's performance.

"I think it's a shame that this would happen, because I think you have a hardworking, honest, intelligent solicitor, and I think she deserves much better than this," he said.

"I don't have a great deal of experience with this procedure," Bianchi said of a no-confidence vote. "They're used very rarely, but they certainly aren't used to promote good government, and they're generally used as a political instrument, to embarrass someone politically.

"I think the people of Pittsfield have heard enough about Spectrum. I was selected to make decisions, and I made one in the best interest of the City of Pittsfield, and I think people are ready to move on."

Sherman had expressed similar sentiments on the Spectrum case to The Berkshire Eagle in late August, when City Councilors Jonathan Lothrop, John Krol and Barry Clairmont first accused the mayor of misleading the council on the litigation, but in light of further review of the documents chose to support Yon in her petition.

"I would have done it for any of my councilors," Sherman told iBerkshires. "I do it mainly for the citizens of Pittsfield, who I feel deserve better solicitation."

Both Sherman and Bianchi stressed that regardless of the outcome of the vote before the council next week, this measure is purely a non-binding advisory action.

"They can take a vote of no confidence, and it means absolutely nothing," Bianchi told iBerkshires. "I think it's a political device, to embarrass a person, to embarrass an administration."

"It's a last resort," said Sherman. "Following the vote, what I hope to have happen is that the concerns that are expressed are really reflected upon and addressed by those who can address them."

The petition will encounter some staunch opposition if it moves forward into deliberations next week, according to at-Large City Councilor Melissa Mazzeo.

"I'm shocked and extremely disappointed by this whole petition," said Mazzeo "I'm hoping that by the time Tuesday rolls around that they come to their senses, and decide to not even go forward with it."

Mazzeo said she questions the judgment of some of her fellow councilors in coming to the conclusions they have on Degnan's performance as the city's legal representative.

"This is what we approved her for, to do this kind of work for us," Mazzeo told iBerkshires. "As far as I know, we don't have any attorneys that sit on the council."

"I'm so disappointed that they're doing this to her, and to the mayor right now. The only thing that I'm getting out of this is that it's a purely political move, because that's what a vote of no confidence means."

Mazzeo indicated her skepticism of the recent controversy over the litigation settlement with Spectrum Health Systems.

"Eventually they were going to get their building permit. We could have been tied up in court for another year or two, denying them their permit, but eventually they would have won. The whole time, ca-ching ca-ching for lawyer's fees." 

Mazzeo sees continued discussion of the litigation as a divisive issue on the council that is interfering with conducting other city business. 

"We can't move forward as a council anymore, because they keep dragging us back," said Mazzeo "I have to move on with my job, and they're nitpicking because she said something incorrectly, or didn't say something the way they wanted it, and that's not their right."

Tags: city council,   city solicitor,   lawsuit,   Spectrum Health,   

iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue; please keep comments focused on the issues and not on personalities. Profanity, obscenity, racist language and harassment are not allowed. iBerkshires reserves the right to ban commenters or remove commenting on any article at any time. Concerns may be sent to info@iberkshires.com.

Cultural Pittsfield This Week: Aug. 23-29

This weekend is your last chance to see the 2019 Pittsfield Shakespeare in the Park production of Much Ado About Nothing. Performances are held on Thursdays, Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays at 8 p.m. on the First Street Common. Featuring the witty on-again, off-again lovers Beatrice and Benedick, Much Ado is the story of the trials of love in a society dominated by patriarchal traditions. Beatrice's cousin Hero and the soldier Claudio meet and fall in love, but when a man spreads nasty rumors about her, Hero's voice is silenced and their relationship torn apart. Loyalties are tested as the community responds, including a ragtag group of officers who just might save the day. FREE, donations suggested.
The Shaker Barn Music Series presents singer-songwriter Nellie McKay. The deep, and deeply funny, McKay has paid tribute to the disparate likes of Doris Day, transgender jazz pianist Billy Tipton, environmentalist Rachel Carson and comedian Joan Rivers. Wallace Field opens. 7:30 p.m.
FRI Blue Light Trio at Rainbow | FRI Karaoke Night at Friends | FRI Dan Gingras at Proprietor's Lodge | FRI Todd McLeod at Rusty Anchor | FRI Mr. Doubtfire at Mission | FRI-SAT Wine, Cheese & Trees at Bousquet | SAT Latin Night at The A | SAT Pete Boyd at Proprietor's Lodge | SAT The Damaged & More at Crossroads | SAT Acoustic Gravel & Jessica Wilson at Rusty Anchor | SUN-MON Karen Mason at Barrington Stage | MON Jazz Night at Mission | TUE Entrepreneurial Meet-up at Thistle & Mirth | WED Melissa Massery at Methuselah | WED Gruppo Mondo at Rainbow | THU The Picky B's at Mission | THU Jessica Wilson at Proprietor's Lodge

Children ages 6 and older are invited to learn to paint a sparkly unicorn on a 16x20 canvas at Berkshire Paint & Sip. All painting materials, instruction, light snacks and non-alcoholic drinks are included in the $25 fee. 1-3 p.m. at 305 North Street.
FRI FREE Fun Friday at Berkshire Museum FRI WeeMuse: Adventures at Berkshire Museum FRI Designing with da Vinci at Berkshire Museum FRI-THU Parenting Classes & Play Groups at 18 Degrees (formerly Berkshire Children & Families) SAT Chow Time at Berkshire Museum SAT Kitchen Ka-Boom! at Berkshire Museum SAT Back to School Event at Berkshire Dream Center SAT Designing with da Vinci at Berkshire Museum SAT Robbins Zust Marionette Show at Dottie's SAT da Vinci After Hours at Berkshire Museum SUN Discovery Tank Program at Berkshire Museum | MON Exploring Our World at Berkshire Museum TUE WeeMuse: Littlest Learners at Berkshire Museum TUE Designing with da Vinci at Berkshire Museum WED Gallery Scavenger Hunts at Berkshire Museum THU Farm Friends at Hancock Shaker Village | THU Exploring Our World at Berkshire Museum THU Designing with da Vinci at Berkshire Museum 
SUN Restorative Yoga w/CBD Massage at Radiance
Indulge in the ultimate self-care experience, combining restorative yoga with CBD massage, at Radiance Yoga. Shannon will lead you through comfortable yoga postures and licensed massage therapists will guide you deeper into relaxation with massage using Vermont Farmacy's Herbal CBD Salve. 6 p.m.
FRI-THU Various Classes at Berkshire Running Center | FRI-THU Various Classes at Berkshire Family YMCA | FRI-THU Various Classes at Berkshire Yoga Dance & Fitness FRI-THU Various Classes at Radiance Yoga | FRI-THU Various Classes at Berkshire Salsa FRI-THU Various Classes at Pilates Fit | SAT Sunrise Yoga on the Deck at Rusty Anchor | SUN Goat Yoga at Hancock Shaker Village SUN Yoga Class at Tyler Street Lab MON Zumba Class at Tyler Street Lab THU Outdoor Yoga at Onota Lake
SAT+ George Gershwin Alone at The Colonial
View Full Story

More Pittsfield Stories