image description

Mazzeo Claims Irregularities as Reason for Mayoral Recount

Staff ReportsPrint Story | Email Story
PITTSFIELD, Mass. — The mayoral election recount on Monday starts at 8:30 a.m. with more than a dozen election workers counting nearly 12,000 votes by hand. 
The recount is being requested by Melissa Mazzeo, who lost the hard fought race against Linda Tyer by 529 votes on Nov. 5. 
Mazzeo's petition for the hand count of ballots listed access to the ballots by unauthorized persons as a main reason. On Friday, she released a statement further detailing that allegation. 
Her statement claims an "individual closely related to the Tyer Campaign" was the person with access to the ballots and that "numerous voters complained about this individual to us."
Mazzeo said her campaign contacted the state Elections Division to report this issue. Another individual reported that their name had been marked as voted  when they had not in fact cast a ballot. This person was unable to vote, according to Mazzeo's statement. 
And a third issue she raised was the "abnormally high amounts of absentee ballots" in this election. 
City Clerk Michele Benjamin told NEPR that the absentee ballots are secured in the vault and that no unauthorized persons would have access to them. However, she also said the number of absentees was higher than usual at about 250 than the last election. 
"After speaking with state elections officials and legal counsel, my campaign went through the formal process of requesting a recount in Pittsfield in order to ensure that all votes were accurately counted and all voters had their voices heard. This is not a decision that I took lightly," Mazzeo said in her statement. "However, I have been advised that it is a necessary step in the process that keeps all viable options open to address the significant concerns my campaign has about the integrity of the election here in Pittsfield. Leading up to and including Election Day, we were informed of a series of events that we believe must be investigated."
The last mayoral recount was in 2009 during another bitter election between James Ruberto and Daniel Bianchi. Ruberto had won election night by a margin of  209 votes out of 13,215 cast; the recount only reduced the margin by two votes in Bianchi's favor. In 2011, Peter Marchetti declined to pursue a recount against Bianchi, who won the corner office that year by only 113 votes.  
Benjamin said she hoped to have the recount concluded in one day. The 2009 recount, with a 1,000 more votes than 2019, took about six hours. Both mayoral candidates will have observers at the counting that will take place in City Council Chambers. 

Tags: election 2019,   recount,   

Comments are closed for this article. If you would like to contribute information on this article, e-mail us at

PEDA Director Thurston Stepping Down in April

By Jack GuerinoiBerkshires Staff
PITTSFIELD, Mass. — The head of the Pittsfield Economic Development Authority is stepping down at the end of April.
Corydon "Cory" Thurston last week announced his retirement as executive director of the development agency he's lead for nine years.
"It has been a positive time and I think there is a new energy and I think one of the best accomplishments is getting the city and PEDA to work collaboratively," Thurston said in an interview Thursday evening.
Thurston had initially planned to retire three years ago but ended up cutting back to part time as PEDA looked to consolidate its office and focus more on collaborating with the city with matters having to do with the William Stanley Business Park and development.
View Full Story

More Pittsfield Stories