WILLIAMSTOWN — The Berkshire Arts and Technology Charter School is once more the focus of controversy, as a former special education teacher plans to file a formal grievance against the principal and has blasted the school for failing to meet the needs of its special education students.
But administrators and a group of special education parents and guardians disputed the charges by former SPED teacher Stacey Elin Rossi and sprang to the school’s defense this week. While no one was willing to use the phrase, the inference was that the charges by amounted to sour grapes.
BArT Director Julia Bowen, while saying she could not comment on personnel matters, defended the school and said, “I do not believe her claims are valid.â€
Rossi, in a letter dated Nov. 3 to the State Ethics Commission, said her dismissal in October was “wrongful,†and that she planned to pursue a complaint against BArT Principal Michelle Close, whom she has charged with unprofessional and unethical conduct and “slipshod leadership.â€
Rossi, a master’s degree candidate at Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts and now an educational consultant based in Pittsfield, said the BArT administration neglected the needs of special education students, openly questioned the need to service those students – who constitute 30 percent of the school’s enrollment – and failed to learn, or abide by, state regulations for educating special needs students.
“A year or so back, public school administrators and other local educators expressed concern about two major issues: That people from outside the area would be directing the school and that provisions for the students, particularly in special education, might be inadequate,†Rossi wrote in a letter to the editors of local newspapers. “Both of these, prophetically, were major problems at BArT when I was there, and, most likely, continue to be. I say this because these factors are systemic to BArT and endemic to the nature of charter schools generally.â€
In her letter to Brett Wingard of the Ethics Commission, a copy of which she provided to The Advocate, Rossi wrote, “My dismissal from BArT was wrongful but more importantly ... Ms. Close’s general conduct was highly unethical and unprofessional.â€
Bowen, speaking by telephone Wednesday, maintained that the school is serving its special needs students well.
“I feel like we’re doing a lot to serve these students, as we do for all students,†she said.
Rossi, also speaking by telephone, said “The principal let me go for really no reason except that I’m a highly ethical person who didn’t like what was going on there.â€
BArT, she said, is “absolutely not geared to be accommodating to the SPED population.â€
“It was seen as a real burden to try to accommodate these kids,†she said. “I was even silenced when I talked about it. My questions were ignored. I was disgusted, really.â€
A former staffer who did not want to be identified but who was familiar with the situation, agreed with Rossi’s allegations.
But Bowen said Rossi’s dismissal was not wrongful and that it took place within the 90-day probationary period during which employees can be let go for any reason. Bowen defended the school’s approach to, and programs for, children with special needs, noting that a recent state Department of Education evaluation found the school in compliance.
“We are a brand new school, but we are delivering the services we need to be delivering,†Bowen said. “After visiting our program, they found that we are doing what we are supposed to be doing. We’ve been in constant contact with them ... They are comfortable with where we are.â€
She added, “We do provide the services that are required in the IEPs [individual education plans].†I work closely with the principal, and the principal does not question the need to service special needs students.â€
Efforts to reach Department of Education officials for comment this week were unsuccessful.
Bowen said the school has a consultant, Norm Carmel, a special education administrator in the public schools for 30 years, who works five to 10 hours a week for BArT. She stressed that the school is, contrary to Rossi’s allegations, equipped to handle special education students as the school promised and as mandated by the state.
Several parents or guardians of special needs students leapt to the school’s defense, describing in glowing terms their children’s progress and the school’s caring and effective approach.
Ronald Gallagher of Williamstown, whose son attends BArT, said, “Our experience has been extremely positive despite the challenges the school has faced, having to work with the limitations of not having their own facility. [The school is temporarily based at Mount Greylock Regional High School while awaiting the renovations of its quarters at One Commercial Place in Adams.]â€
“My son has flourished in a number of ways due to the exceptional teaching staff they have in place,†Gallagher said. “One of the reasons we had an interest in having him go there was the personalized attention. He is especially interested in the visual arts, and he has done work there that has far exceeded any expectations.â€
He added, “They have done a wonderful job evaluating his special needs and working to find ways that can be adapted to those needs. We have been pleasantly surprised by just how positive an experience it has been for us.â€
Marianne Riello of Adams has two grandchildren, ages 14 and 13, at BArT, and praised the school’s special education program.
“Michelle [Close] has been great,†Riello said. “She’s gone out of her way to do things.â€
Faith Piaggi of North Adams, another parent of a child with special needs, said she has also had a positive experience.
“I definitely think BArT has met my child’s needs,†she said. “I feel they followed through with the learning environment they proposed to have. I feel they definitely have done everything they can to help here.â€
She added, “They give her support when that’s what she needs, and extra help. Anything she has, they hop on it right away — they don’t wait for me to ask. I’m very, very happy. She’s had a very good year this year.â€
Nancy Hart of Williamstown, a guardian ad litem, appointed by juvenile court for children in need or in state Department of Social Services custody, said BArT is “beyond anything I’ve ever seen.â€
“I have been overwhelmed with the care and trust and support the staff of the school has given to these children,†Hart said, referring to the two special needs children she is guardian for. “They [school officials] go to meetings with me in Pittsfield. They go out of their way, way beyond anything I’ve ever seen to support and nurture both children, who are in different classes at different levels.â€
And, said Hart, the school “communicates very well with all the people involved.â€
“For the most part, the foster parents are very, very happy with BArt services to the children,†she said.
Rossi expressed regret, as did her former colleague, that the school has, in her opinion, not fulfilled its potential and its original mission.
“It had a very ambitious mission,†Rossi said. “If it had been executed, it could be a great place.â€
She added, “I think the school did not want to be accommodating to SPED kids. There was a lot of lip service, but anyone who questions the way things are done and stands up for the rights of parents and students is considered out of line.â€
Close, the principal, said, “I think we have worked very hard. I have worked very hard to meet special needs of students. We just had our Department of Education review and we got nothing but great responses. I feel very confident that we’re meeting the needs of our special needs students.â€
She added, “We love our special needs students as we do our other students, and we work to serve the needs of everyone. As we hire a new SPED teacher and take the candidates around to the classrooms, we never mention that these are SPED students and these are regular students. Full inclusion has worked quite nicely. Every person counts.â€
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.
Your Comments
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
No Comments
Youth For The Future: Adwita Arunkumar
By Breanna SteeleiBerkshires Staff
PITTSFIELD, Mass. — Williams Elementary School fourth-grader Adwita Arunkumar has been selected as our April Youth for the Future for her mentoring of a younger child.
Youth for the Future is a 12-month series that honors young individuals that have made an impact on their community. This year's sponsor is Patriot Car Wash. Nominate a youth here.
Adwita has cortical visual impairment; she has been working with her teacher, Lynn Shortis, and her, paraprofessional Nadine Henner.
"My journey with CVI means that I learned in a different way. I work hard every day with Miss Henner and Miss Lynn, to show how smart I am," she said.
"Adwita is a remarkable student. She's a remarkable child. She has, as she shared, cortical visual impairment, which is a brain-based visual processing disorder, which means the information coming in through the eyes is interfered with somewhere along the pathways, and we never quite know what's being interpreted and how and how it's being seen," said Shortis.
"So she has a lot of accommodations and specialized instruction to help her learn."
Recently Adwita has chosen to mentor 4-year-old Cayden Ziemba, who is also visually impaired.
"I decided to be a mentor to Cayden so that she can learn some new things. I teach her how to walk with the cane, with the diagonal and tap technique, I am teaching her Braille," she said. "I enjoy spending time with Cayden, playing games and being a good role model."
Shortis said the mentoring opportunity came up when Cayden was entering preschool at Williams, and they introduced her to Adwita.
"Adwita works really, really hard academically. She's very smart, but there are a lot of challenges in that, because of the way that it's so visual and she's a natural. She's just, it's automatic," Shortis said. "It's kind of like a switch is turned on and she becomes this extremely confident and proud person in this teacher role."
Adwita also has been helping Cayden on how to use her cane on the bus and became a mentor in a unexpected ways.
"Immediately at the start of this year, she would meet Cayden at the bus. She has taught Cayden how to use her cane to go down the bus stairs. Again, Adwita learned that skill, so it wasn't something I had to say to her, this is what you need to have Cayden do. She just automatically picked that up and transferred that information," said Shortis. "Cayden is now going down the bus step steps independently with her cane. And then she really works hard with Adwita in traveling through the hallways, Adwita leads her to her class every morning, helps her put her things away and get ready for her morning."
Adwita said she hopes Cayden can feel excited about school and that other students can feel good about themselves as well.
"I want them to know that Braille is cool to learn. You can feel the bumpiness with your fingers. I want people to know how you can still learn if your brain works differently sometimes. I need to have a lot of patience working with a 3-year-old. I need to be creative and energized," she said.
She hopes to one day take her mentoring skills to the head of the class as a teacher.
"I want to become a teacher and teach other students when I grow up. I might want to teach math, because I am great at it," she said. "I also want to teach others about CVI. CVI doesn't stop me from being able to do anything I want to. I want students to not feel stressed out and know that they can do anything they want by working hard and persevering."
Her one-to-one paraprofessional said she likes seeing the bond that has grown between the two girls, and can picture Adwita being a teacher one day.
"I do see her in the future being a teacher because of her patience, understanding and just natural-born instinctive skills on how to work with young children," Henner said.
Shortis also said their bond is quite special and their relationship has helped to bring out the confidence in each other.
"The beauty of it, there's just something about it their bond is, I don't even really have a word to describe the bond that the two of them have. I think they share something in common, that they're both visually impaired, and regardless of the fact that their visual impairment differs and the you know the cause of it differs," she said.
"They can relate. And they both have the cane. They're both learning some Braille. But there's something else that's there that just the two of them connected immediately, and you see it. You just you see it in their overall relationship."
Qwanell Bradley scored 33 points, and Adan Wicks added 29 as the Hoosac Valley boys basketball team won a Division 5 State Championship on Sunday. click for more
Adan Wicks scored 38 points, and the eighth-seeded Hoosac Valley basketball team Saturday rallied from a nine-point first-half deficit to earn a 76-67 win over top-seeded Drury in the Division 5 State Quarter-Finals. click for more
Caprese Conyers scored 22 points, and Kyana Summers had a double-double with 10 points and 13 rebounds to go with eight assists as Pittsfield got back to the state semi-finals for the second year in a row. click for more