Mass MoCA to Remove 'Training Ground' materials

By Tammy DanielsPrint Story | Email Story
A house from Houghton Street was cut up to fit into Building 5 for 'Training Ground.' (Mass MoCA)
NORTH ADAMS - The detritus that was to be Swiss artist Christoph Buchel's first major American installation is being hauled out of Massachusetts Museum of Contemporary Art. Describing the unfinished "Training Ground For Democracy" as "abandoned materials," museum officials said the massive Building 5 gallery will be cleared for a new exhibition in November. “With several hundred tons of materials and thousands of objects and partial constructions sitting abandoned in our galleries, we carefully considered what we could do,” Joseph C. Thompson, Mass MoCA’s director, said in a statement late Tuesday."We obviously cared a great deal for the work and had expended extraordinary effort and energies to try to bring it into existence; we did not want to act precipitously in either dismantling or displaying it. With no other options, and wanting to move forward as the situation continued to draw resources away from other artists and public programming, we sought a declaration of our respective rights by an impartial party – a federal judge.” The museum spent more than $300,000 - double the estimated budget - on the installation, which was to include a wrecked North Adams Police cruiser, a house moved from Hougton Street, one of the theaters from the old North Adams Cinema and numerous items donated by local residents. But the museum balked at trying to get the fuselage of a jetliner and Buchel walked off in late 2006 and never returned. The exhibit, which was to open last December, was covered with yellow tarps as the two sides tried to settle the dispute, only to land in court. Judge Michael A. Ponsor of U.S. District Court in Springfield on Friday rejected Buchel's claims that the museum had violated his rights under the Visual Artists Rights Act of 1990 by allowing the public to see parts of the exhibit. Buchel cited a tour of the exhibit by Gov. Deval Patrick as evidence. The judge, however, ruled the act didn't apply to unfinished work. In his summary judgement, Ponsor said the museum had the right to display the work or not since it had supplied funding and labor. If the installation was put on display, Buchel had the right to request a disclaimer. According to The Boston Globe, Buchel has decided to appeal the decision. Museum officials said they had "explored every possible avenue in an effort to re-engage the artist, and when those efforts proved futile, the museum offered him the opportunity to retrieve the materials from the museum galleries (reimbursing the museum for its costs), which he declined to do." The exhibit was canceled in May and the museum requested a declaratory judgment from the court on its and the artist's rights over the unfinished work. "We are deeply appreciative of the court’s thoughtful scrutiny of this matter," said Thompson in the statement. "After giving careful deliberation to the interests of many constituents, including the artist’s own views, and factoring in the limited time window available given our normal exhibition cycle - together with other considerations both logistical and philosophical - we have decided to begin removing the materials immediately without placing them on public display." A new exhibition, Jenny Holzer’s "Projections," will open in the space Nov. 17. The museum also said it would co-host a symposium with the Clark Art Institute devoted to the issues raised by this case. The symposium will be held later this fall. Meanwhile, Buchel will open a new installation later this month at the Los Angeles Contemporary Exhibitions that is described as "a commentary on past and present military agendas." It will include replicas of missiles, bombs, and other military equipment stashed away as if hidden and forgotten in a small waiting room, discovered only after walking through a series of adjacent rooms and doors.
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.

Letter: Building a More Sustainable North Adams

Letter to the Editor

To the Editor:

Last week, the North Adams City Council voted unanimously to expand the scope of our existing Tree Commission and create a new Sustainability & Tree Commission. I think this is an important move towards building a more sustainable city, for our future and the future of our children.

This wasn't the work of any one person. A lot of people put time and thought into getting us here. I want to thank my fellow councilors, who worked together to make the commission stronger; Mayor Macksey and her administration, who supported this change from the beginning; Tree Commission Chair Stephen Betti, who gave the proposal his blessing and spoke up in support of it; the members of the Inclusion, Diversity, Equity, and Access Commission, whose review helped make the language more inclusive; and the members of Green NA, who provided encouragement, guidance, and advocacy throughout this process.

The new commission will continue the important work of caring for and planting North Adams' trees while taking on a much broader role in thinking about our city's environmental future. It will advise the City on issues including energy efficiency, renewable energy, climate resilience, natural resource conservation, recycling and waste reduction, water management, biodiversity, sustainable development, and more. And importantly, the commission will have a role in public education, community engagement, pursuing grants and partnerships, and working with other boards, departments, and regional organizations.

The next step is to build the commission.

Assuming all three members of our current Tree Commission stay on, and I certainly hope they do, we will need four new members appointed by the mayor. The ordinance encourages the appointment of at least one young person under the age of 25, because we all believe young people should have a seat at the table when we talk about the future of their community.

If you are interested in helping build a more sustainable North Adams, I encourage you to consider applying by filling out the city's Boards & Commissions application and selecting "Tree Commission" here: 

Whether you join this commission or simply find another way to get involved, I hope you will participate. North Adams needs people who care enough to roll up their sleeves and help build the future, one tree planting at a time.

View Full Story

More North Adams Stories