To the Editor:

The question of experience comes up during elections. At nearly 80, John Barrett III unquestionably has more years with nearly half a century as a career politician, but longevity does not guarantee stronger leadership or better outcomes, especially if we are looking forward to 10 years. Andrew Fitch who has worked non-political jobs across a wider range of roles in half that time, can bring broader skills, fresh perspectives, and a more adaptable approach to public service.

Election results show that years served do not define effectiveness or one would have the people's support. The majority, 60 percent, voted against Barrett in this same state primary nine years ago. Longevity matters, but so do community connection, collaboration, and the ability to evolve with changing needs. Serving as a state representative is very different from being a mayor. A representative is one of 160 members, not a singular executive authority, and the role requires coalition building, negotiation, and networking which has never been one of Barrett's finest attributes.

Long-standing community priorities require consistent advocacy, such as completing the North Adams bike path connection to Adams and Williamstown. Former state Rep. Gail Cariddi championed this project, and Barrett said he would finish her work when he first ran, yet North Adams is no further along. In contrast, Fitch on the City Council is respectful but persistent, pushing issues until answers, progress, and resolutions emerge.

We need someone who works well with others, not someone who relies on intimidation or positional authority. A heavy-handed style doesn't work in a large legislative body, with members averaging 30 years younger than Barrett. Small wins may look like progress, but the state distributes billions of which some reaches us no matter who holds the seat. The real question is whether we could secure more funding for roads, infrastructure, public safety, and economic development, or is the status quo of what we received the past 10 years acceptable to you?

Having served alongside both candidates on the council, I've seen how their styles shape outcomes. While one on council struggled to gain support for anything because their authoritarian approach created conflict, the other has consistently moved ideas forward through collaboration and shared credit.

That contrast may explain why Fitch consecutively lands first for City Council elections, and Barrett — despite his years as mayor before losing two elections — finished sixth. For me, the choice is straightforward: Andrew Fitch for State Representative.

Keith Bona
North Adams, Mass. 

Keith Bona is a North Adams city councilor.