image description

Pittsfield Mayoral Candidates Spar on Finances, Accountability

By Tammy DanielsiBerkshires Staff
Print Story | Email Story

Nicholas J. Caccamo, Patricia 'Pam' Malumphy, Mayor James M. Ruberto, Mark A. Marciano and Rick E. Moon prepare to match wits in the PCTV studio.
PITTSFIELD, Mass. — A free-flowing forum on Friday with nine of the 10 candidates for mayor focused on finances and government transparency.

Incumbent James M. Ruberto, seeking a fourth term, defended his administration's financial acumen and his ability to shepherd the city through the continuing economic crisis. He cited the success of his tenure for sparking one of the largest mayoral races in some time.

"I think one of the reasons why we are seeing such interest in this mayoral race is because we've shown over the last six years what progressive government does," he said. "It produces results and it allows everyone to feel that the more engaged they can be in the process, the greater their opportunity to serve."

But his challengers said Ruberto's administration has seen property taxes go up and has failed to fully reveal budget details and certain project funding.

Moderated by local commentator Daniel Valenti, whose columns appear in The Pittsfield Gazette and The Berkshire Eagle, the 90-minute session was taped at Pittsfield Community Television. Valenti put the forum together at short notice because only one other forum, sponsored by PCTV, the Gazette and Berkshire Community College, has been scheduled before the Sept. 22 preliminary election.

Seated from left to right at two tables slightly facing each other and according to their position on the ballot, were Nicholas J. Caccamo, Patricia "Pam" Malumphy, Ruberto, Mark A. Marciano, Rick E. Moon, Daniel L. Bianchi, Paul Kwasniowski, Lisa M. Boyd and Jeffrey W. Ferrin. Stephen A. Fillio did not attend.

Valenti asked questions and also allowed responses between candidates. Ruberto, Bianchi (Ward 6 councilor) and Malumphy (a former councilor) dominated much of the conversation.

Malumphy said her work as regional director for the state Office of Business Development gave her insight into the needs of businesses to grow jobs while Bianchi pointed to his past service as the city's financial officer and on the control board that oversaw spending when the city was in financial crisis some years ago. Both called for greater cooperation and collaboration with surrounding communities.

Caccamo, a recent graduate of Champlain College, said the city should look to sustainability and efficiency to save costs. "When we cultivate a 'Buy Berkshires' mindset it'll allow us to take more control over our economic sitution and will allow us to weather national economic trends."

Marciano and Kwasniowski both said the city should look into energy savings, with Kwasniowski also adding that public safety should be the No. 1 priority: "We need to get these gangs out of Pittsfield."

Boyd, an accountant, said better planning and budget analysis could find savings. Several candidates pointed to specific spending items they said should be eliminated or changed to save money, such as outsourcing services, relying on paper mail rather e-mail, and freezing hiring.


Daniel L. Bianchi, Paul Kwasniowski and Lisa M. Boyd wait for a question from Daniel Valenti. (Jeffrey W. Ferrin is also seated at the table.)
Ruberto disagreed with Ferrin's assertion that supplying city workers and police with global positioning systems and cell phones was wasteful spending. "When [police] get on the squawk box, not only do you know they're coming — the druggies know they're coming, too."

The candidates split on whether to impose a 2 percent local rooms tax, which Ruberto supports. "If it passes, we will take those revenues and we will offset ... property taxes," said Ruberto.

Malumphy said she could support at most a 1 percent increase because "it feels like we're taxing our way out of everything." Ferrin agreed, as long as there was accountability. Marciano's, Moon's and Kwasniowski's answers were all no; Caccamo's and Boyd's both yes. "Taxes are going up for everyone, why not for them, too?" said Boyd.

Bianchi said it was an issue for cooperation with other communities, "to make sure the city of Pittsfield isn't disadvantaged."

The talk of taxes lead to issues of government transparency. Ferrin complained that his quest for cell-phone costs for the city resulted in a counter demand for $2,145 to compile the information. "If someone walks into an office and asks for this information, it should be readily available," said Ferrin.

Boyd, too, said her efforts to track down spending items, including the $750,000 of work on Wahconah Park, was stymied. "There's no reason why numbers aren't available two weeks out."

Malumphy said the lack of transparency was one of the "tipping points" that had propelled her candidacy. She had helped Wahconah abutter Jenny Hersch file a petition for details on work there that has gone unanswered two months later. Bianchi, however, targeted the Pittsfield Economic Development Authority for not operating in a transparent manner: "Anything of any substance goes in executive session."

Caccamo, when asked by Valenti, said the city's budget process is "about as open as it gets."

Ruberto said initiatives undertaken during his tenure have been open, starting "with a conversation, they move forward in some cases with public hearings, in some cases with ad hoc committees, in some cases with neighborhood groups."

There's also an effort to ensure full information is available, because "incomplete information will lead to more questions," said Ruberto, adding the Wahconah numbers will be released after all "the expenses are duly reported."

Moon's take was more philosophical: "You don't fight the darkness; you turn on the light and make it go away,"

Marciano launched a spirited attack on Malumphy and Bianchi, questioning what they had done to further openness and claiming Malumphy had ignored the calls of a North Street business. Ruberto jumped to Malumphy's defense, saying it was unfair to use anecdotal evidence against anyone. (Malumphy later provided iBerkshires an e-mail from the business in question, thanking her for speaking with them.)

The candidates also touched lightly on the role of PEDA, public safety and education. The entire, unedited forum is scheduled to be broadcast on PCTV on Tuesday, Sept. 1, at 8:30 p.m.; Sept. 2 at 3:30 and 11 a.m., Sept. 5 at 5 p.m. and Sept. 6 at 1 and 10 a.m.

The candidates will next meet in BCC's Boland Theatre on Monday, Sept. 14, at 7 p.m.
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.

Berkshire Scenic Railway Rails Against Acts of Vandalism

Staff Reports

LENOX, Mass. — Berkshire Scenic Railway Museum (BSRM) released a statement appealing to the Lenox community, local parents, and the public for accountability and support after kids allegedly entered the museum's rail yard and vandalized historic rail equipment.

The release stated that there were three separate occasions of vandalism that caused more than $25,000 in intentional damage.

"We are heartbroken, exhausted, and deeply frustrated," said Melanie Seiden, Executive Director of the Berkshire Scenic Railway Museum. "As a small non-profit already pouring everything we have into recovering from the recent fire in Adams, we simply cannot absorb $25,000 in senseless, unnecessary destruction. Beyond the costs, this is taxing for our volunteers who dedicate a tremendous amount of time to restoring this equipment. How can we even account for the hours these individuals are going to need to put in to undo this senseless damage. Every dollar diverted to replacing smashed windows and repairing vandalized coaches is money taken directly away from preserving Berkshire County's railroad history and serving the families who visit us."

On Monday, Nov. 9, 2026, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026, and Monday, Nov. 16, 2026—the museum alleges that juveniles trespassed onto the Lenox property and deliberately vandalized multiple pieces of the museum's vintage fleet, smashing windows on historic rail cars, defacing equipment, writing profanities, and attempting to kick in the door of a passenger coach.

BSRM reports that all occurrences were captured on the museum's surveillance cameras, and the Nov. 9 incident was also witnessed by an employee at the neighboring building, who intervened and caused the group to scatter.

The Lenox Police Department responded to file a full report and has reviewed the museum's surveillance footage, positively identifying at least one juvenile suspect as the investigation continues.

This comes at a time when Museum leadership and volunteers are already working towards a major restoration and recovery effort following the October 24 fire in Adams, Massachusetts, which caused extensive damage to the museum's historic New Haven 41 equipment.

"As a parent of two teenagers myself, I want the parents of these youths to hear me. Coming onto our property and intentionally destroying our equipment not once, but on three separate occasions, shows they firmly believe there will be no consequences for their actions. Watching and listening to our surveillance footage was truly devastating—it was unmistakable that they knew exactly what they were doing, and worse, they were proud of it. Our volunteers pour their hearts into preserving this history, and we are all heartbroken," Seiden said. "Shielding young people from the consequences of intentional destruction does not help them. Set aside the fact that these kids don't have $25,000 lying around—where is the respect, where is the empathy, where is basic human goodness? Lenox prides itself on being a tight-knit community, and if we let this go unchecked, what message are we sending our youth?"

The museum is actively cooperating with the Lenox Police Department to seek full restitution and appropriate accountability so that the financial burden of these three incidents does not fall on donors, volunteers, and the public.

BSRM asks anyone who may have additional information about the incidents to contact the Lenox Police Department.

Community members who wish to support ongoing preservation and restoration efforts can visit www.berkshiretrains.org.

 

View Full Story

More Lenox Stories