Mixed Reactions From Local Voters on Presidential Debate

By Joe DurwinPittsfield Correspondent
Print Story | Email Story

Early arrivals and members of the press get settled in to watch the first presidential debate on Wednesday.
PITTSFIELD, Mass. — Despite the overall liberal orientation of the crowd, opinions were fairly diverse among debate watchers at Dottie's Coffee Lounge on Wednesday night over who "won" the night's verbal jousting match.

The debate is one of three presidential debates which the North Street eatery and downtown social hub will show projected on the big screen.

"Dottie's is a community that I feel like I belong to," said regular customer Eammon Barry on his reasoning for coming out to the cafe for this event. "So watching the debate here feels like I'm being responsible to that community, and my friends."

From the start, it was clear that the approximately 35 attendees, ranging from too-young-to-vote to middle-aged, contained no die-hard Mitt Romney supporters, though from the undertones of dissatisfaction with President Obama it was clear that this crowd could not be considered the core base of the Democratic campaign either.

Through the course of the 90-minute debate, it was Obama's quips and off-hand jibes that elicited more noise of approval from the room than any particular policy point or rebuttal. Meanwhile, Romney's remarks about his opponent drew less reaction than his references to economic mathematics, which tended to provoke a gradually louder laughter that began to turn more to occasional expletives in the final half hour.

After it was over, reactions were mixed on who had performed better. 

"I don't think there was any question about who won," said Justin Allen. "I think the president made Romney look dumb."

"Romney won. Obama let him slide on a lot," said active Democratic activist Timothy Kushi. "One is citing this study, one is citing that study, and the public isn't going to read those studies. It just looked like they were arguing two different sets of facts."

"It's just so frustrating," continued Kushi, "because there's so much that they discussed, and Obama let him get away with so much. I think Romney was clearly the winner."

"Mitt won, based on sheer time possession," said another man, who like many expressed displeasure with the loose moderation style of Jim Lehrer, executive editor of the PBS NewsHour.

Many felt that the former governor brought more passion and emotion to his side of the debate, though not all found it believable.

"The emotion almost seemed like part of him trying to hard," said Margaret, an Oregon resident who was just in the area for a few weeks.

Who lost the debate?
Obama
Romney
Lehrer
The American people
Big Bird
Who cares? Bobby V is gone!
In addition to members of the conventional press, local spoken word artist Jay Davis covered the event from a poetical approach, crafting a comedic three-page opus from his observations that lampooned some of the perceived frivolities of both candidates' performances, and asked such questions as whether Jim Lehrer equals Big Bird, and how the two candidates would come out on "Whose Line Is It, Anyway?"

Davis also conducted an informal exit poll of about half the crowd after the debate, resulting in a tally of seven who felt Obama won, four who said Romney won, two undecided and one who felt it was a draw.

"I'd call it a draw," said Davis. "I'd put these three [two undecided and one draw answer] under Romney, because it was such an Obama-heavy crowd to begin with."

On the overall event, Dottie's proprietor Jessica Lamb was pleased, and looks forward to hosting the next two on Oct. 16 and 22.

"I was really pleased with how it all came together," said Lamb. "I thought it was the perfect amount of people." 

"I thought there was a little less enthusiasm than I had anticipated," she told iBerkshires, conceding that the attendance was not particularly balanced by political persuasion. Both staff and patrons agreed: Subsequent debates could use more Republicans.

Tags: debate,   obama,   president,   Romney,   

If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.

BHS Provider Clinics Win MHQP Patient Experience Awards

PITTSFIELD, Mass. — Berkshire Health Systems (BHS) announced that three of its primary care provider clinics have received awards from Massachusetts Health Quality Partners (MHQP) for being among the top practices in Massachusetts for patient experience in primary care.
 
The "MHQP Patient Experience Awards" is an annual awards program introduced in 2018 by MHQP, a non-profit measurement and reporting organization that works to improve the quality of patient care experiences in Massachusetts. MHQP conducts the only statewide survey of patient experience in primary care in Massachusetts.
 
"The teams at Adams Internists, Berkshire Internists and Lenox Family Health have worked extremely hard to provide their patients with the highest standard of compassionate, patient-centered care," said James Lederer, MD, BHS Chief Medical Officer and Chief Quality Officer. "Berkshire Health Systems is pleased by this recognition, which validates that our patients are receiving the quality communication, care, and support that they deserve, which is our highest priority."
 
Awards were given to top overall performers in adult primary care and pediatrics in each of nine performance categories. Adams Internists of BMC, Berkshire Internists of BMC and Lenox Family Health Center of BMC received recognition for the following awards for adult care:
  • Adams Internists of BMC: Distinction in Assessment of Patient Behavioral Health Issues
  • Berkshire Internists of BMC: Distinction in Patient-Provider Communications and How Well Providers Know Their Patients
  • Lenox Family Health Center of BMC: Distinction in Patient-Provider Communications and Office Staff Professional Experience
"It is not easy for a primary care practice to thrive in the current environment," said Barbra Rabson, MHQP's President and CEO. "We are thrilled to congratulate each of them on behalf of their patients for their exceptional commitment to excellence."
 
"Primary care is the foundation of our health care system," said Julita Mir, MD, MHQP's Board Chair. "The practices from all across the state recognized with this award have distinguished themselves where it matters most – in the experiences of their own patients."
View Full Story

More Pittsfield Stories