Letters: Just Do the Math

Letters to the EditorPrint Story | Email Story

To the Editor:

The controversy over the removal of conservation land for the purpose of development of affordable housing in Williamstown continues to ratchet up.

Many letters have raised the question of at what cost. Equally as important as being good stewards of conservation land it is likewise as important to be good stewards of those monies that will allow Williamstown to provide the greatest number of affordable, fiscally responsible and ecologically sensible housing to those in need.

The development and infrastructure costs of the conceptual plan to create 41 building lots on the Lowry property would approximate a $45,000 to $50,000 land cost per unit before any vertical construction of housing. That is an infrastructure cost alone approaching $2,000,000.The other vacant town sites, Photech and 59 Water St., along with a third privately owned vacant site referenced to as Cable Mills South, would only require development and infrastructure costs approximating $10,000 to $15,000 land cost per unit before any vertical construction.  


That represents an opportunity to create affordable housing in Williamstown at a ratio of 3 to 1 on these alternative sites. Not to mention the economies of scale in the construction of mixed-use housing as opposed to single family dwellings that will not provide the same long term economies of maintenance, upkeep and energy efficiency. With 35 years of career experience in the acquisition, development and marketing of real estate, including affordable-housing site selection and more specifically land development in no less than 25 different states, myself along with most anyone who has developed property would tell you that those numbers just don't work to the favor of developing the Lowry property when considering other alternatives.

Putting aside all of the controversies spinning around the issues of affordable housing and conservation land, I ask town officials and the public at large, "just do the math."
 

Robert J. Scerbo
Williamstown
April 13, 2013


Tags: affordable housing,   conserved land,   lowry property,   

If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.

Williamstown Planning Board Narrows Focus for 2027 Bylaw Proposals

By Stephen DravisiBerkshires Staff
WILLIAMSTOWN, Mass. — The Planning Board last week settled on at least three warrant articles it wants to bring to town meeting in May 2027.
 
It plans to use the next few months to finalize the details of exactly what it proposes to plan to the town's legislative body.
 
"There are three warrant articles: one for undersized lots for the Seasonal Communities designation, one for common driveways and one I'm calling an omnibus or cleanup article to change 'Selectmen' to 'Select Board' and other things," Chair Kenneth Kuttner said at the outset of the board's November meeting.
 
The largest of the three proposals grows out of a review of the town's zoning bylaw by consultants at Northampton planning firm Dodson and Flinker.
 
One of the things the consultant found is that while the town replaced the term "Board of Selectmen" with "Select Board" in the town charter, the zoning bylaw still has vestigial references to the former term.
 
Another change would create a citation to the "low-impact development" design practices that the board plans to include in the subdivision control bylaw, which, unlike the zoning bylaw, is a creation of the board and does not go through the town meeting process.
 
At their Nov. 10 meeting, the planners also talked about a couple of updates proposed by Dodson and Flinker that may or may not make it into the final bylaw amendment draft.
 
View Full Story

More Williamstown Stories