State Orders Pittsfield To Release Contested Documents

By Joe DurwinPittsfield Correspondent
Print Story | Email Story
The Human Rights Commission earlier this year. The secretary of the commonwealth ordered the release of documents — mostly emails, letters and meeting minutes — related to a discrimination case brought against Mayor Daniel Bianchi.

PITTSFIELD, Mass. — Following a several month process of appeals and review, the Public Records Division of the secretary of the commonwealth has ordered the release of requested documents pertaining to the city's Human Rights Commission's investigation of a complaint against Mayor Daniel Bianchi.

"The City and the HRC are hereby ordered to provide the responsive records to Mr. Durwin in a manner consistent with this order, the Public Records Law and its Access Regulations," stated Supervisor of Records Shawn Williams in a formal letter, citing insufficient legal support for the denial of these records by City Solicitor Kathleen Degnan.

This order follows a multistep process in the wake of a public records request filed on July 2, 2014, requesting all documents provided to the Human Rights Commission related to its investigation of a formal complaint against Bianchi filed by Medford resident Doreen Wade.

On July 8, City Clerk Linda Tyer responded to indicate that this request had been denied, following an advisement by Degnan that these records were exempt Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 4, Section 7, Clause 26, Paragraph (c), that "personnel and medical files or information; also any other materials or data relating to a specifically named individual, the disclosure of which may constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy."

"If someone makes a public records request, during the middle of an investigation, my answer would be no," Degnan explained to the commission at its July 22 meeting. "Who would want to file a complaint to this body knowing that everything they say and everything they mention would be scrutinized by the public?"

According to the state records authorities, however, the rationale provided in the solicitor's denial failed to meet the requirements of the law cited. Following an appeal by this correspondent, the supervisor of records on Aug. 22 issued a decision overturning the record denial, indicating that this law clearly states "the burden shall be upon the custodian to prove with specificity the exemption which applies."

"It is my finding that the City has failed to satisfy its burden in responding to this records request," Williams wrote. "The City has provided no specificity with respect to the applicability of the exemption claimed and is not permitted to issue a blanket denial without providing any further information with respect to the requested records."

At this time, the state ordered that the requested records be turned over, or that an appeal be filed providing more specific information for the denial. Opting for the latter option, on Sept. 3, Degnan issued a response, expanding on the relevance of the previously cited exemption, and citing an additional exemption to MGL c.4, sec.7cl(26)(f), for "investigatory materials compiled out of the public view by law enforcement or other investigatory officials."

"The Human Rights Commission has the power to create a subcommittee; one of them being tasked to investigate the claims of a Complainant," wrote Degnan in the Sep. 3 appeal. "Said subcommittee is exempt from Open Meeting law as they do not deliberate upon any matter, they simply ask questions."

At the time, no subcommittees of the Human Rights Commission existed. A subcommittee to investigate Wade's complaint was first formed at its Nov. 13 meeting.



Additionally, concern about the possibility of a lawsuit was cited as a reason for the denial in the appeal.

"The City submits that, if the notes, memoranda and documents that were received and/or created during the course of this investigation were disclosed, that both the Human Rights Commission, as well as the City of Pittsfield, risk the initiation of litigation by the Complainant on the grounds that her personal privacy was violated," wrote Degnan.

In response, on Oct. 6, an attorney for the Supervisor of Records' office notified this correspondent that it had requested the City to submit to an "in camera" (i.e., private) review of the records in question in order to help make a determination on the validity of the exemption.

Following this review, the Supervisor of Records issued a determination on Dec. 11 that the exemptions cited were insufficient to warrant continued withholding of the records

"In a letter that accompanied the in camera materials you identified records that the HRC believes are not exempt from disclosure," wrote Williams.

Furthermore, the continued inactivity of any investigation since the abrupt adjournment of the HRC's July meeting prompted the commonwealth to find that statements in the city's appeal indicating release of the records would adversely affect "the HRC's ability to conduct a fair and thorough investigation" were no longer valid.

"It appears that many months have passed since this complaint was filed," Williams stated, "and no information was provided to this office by you, the City or the HRC to indicate that any investigation is active at this time."

Accordingly, the commonwealth ordered on Dec. 11 that the city release all requested documents. On Dec. 29, Degnan issued a notification of its intent to disclose 200 pages of records pertaining to the complaint against Bianchi by Wade.

Here is Part One and Part Two of a story on what was in the documents.
 

Notice of Decision- Pittsfield HRC Records

 


Tags: human rights,   municipal complaint,   public records,   secretary of state,   

If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.

Companion Corner: Dinorah at Berkshire Humane Society

By Breanna SteeleiBerkshires Staff

PITTSFIELD, Mass. – There is a sweet and affectionate cat awaiting a new home at the Berkshire Humane Society.

Dinorah is a black medium haired girl roughly eight years old and has been at the shelter for about a month.

Feline/small animal adoption counselor Alyssa Petell introduced us to her. 

"She's a very sweet senior kitty that we have right now. She's very affectionate, very loving, and very food motivated," she said.

She was found as a stray and they estimate she is between six and 12 years old based on her teeth. Since she is a stray they don't have much background on her but from what they have learned so far, she is sweet and loves food.

"When she originally came in, she was found as a stray, so we don't have a ton of background info on her, but she's doing really well so far," she said. "So as I said before, she's very food motivated. She loves her treats. She loves her food. She also loves chin scratches and all the love. She's just a very affectionate lady."

Dinorah would do best as the only cat and with older children.

"The perfect home for Dinorah is a home with no other kitties," she said. "She would have to be the only cat. I would say no young kids, since she is a senior. She prefers just a nice, quiet home with her perfect person."

This month is adopt senior month and if you adopt a senior cat or dog at the Humane Society you will get half off the adoption fee.

"The great thing about adopting a senior kitty is they are basically already set in their ways with their personality," she said. "They kind of know how to do everything already. They tend to be much more on the calmer side as opposed to adopting a kitten." 

While even though Dinorah is considered a senior she still has a lot of life to give

"Even though our senior kitties are on the older side, they still have plenty more years to go. As I said, Dinorah could be between six and 12, and cats can live up into their late 20s," she said.

While she can take a little bit to warm up, like most cats, she loves to get treats delicately taking it from your hand and head butting you for pets and butt scratches. 

"So Dinorah here is a little shy in the beginning, but she does warm up pretty quickly," she said.  "And one big thing to help her warm up to you is her favorite thing, which would be treats."

You can visit Dinorah at the Berkshire Humane Society and read more about her on the website.

View Full Story

More Pittsfield Stories