Parent Michele Whitney said Cheshire has a larger playground than Plunkett that was partially funded by the PTG. She was one of several parents to stand up in support of the school.
CHESHIRE, Mass. — Residents and officials from Cheshire and Adams sparred over the probable closure of an elementary school on Monday night.
Superintendent Robert Putnam had been expected to make recommendations to the Audit & Evaluation subcommittee prior to the forum but instead reiterated the pros and cons.
The auditorium at Cheshire Elementary was packed on Monday night for the second of two public forums scheduled by the Adams-Cheshire Regional School Committee to gather public input to help inform their decision on which school to close. It was far cry from the much sparser crowd in Adams last week.
As in Adams, Cheshire officials made it clear that they, too, need an elementary school.
"In Cheshire, this school is part of the heart and soul of this community," Cheshire Selectman Robert Ciskowski said. "We don't have a Commercial Street or Howland Avenue with all of the industry. We don't have all those clubs, restaurants and bars."
"This school is integral to this community and if it closes, it will leave a gap in our town. ... If the Cheshire School closes it is going to gut us."
Cheshire Principal Peter Bachli said the school is in better condition than Adams town officials let on and said if it remains open, there will be more transportation reimbursement revenue that can be used to fund needed programs.
Also, he said he was discouraged that during the last forum Adams officials barely mentioned education.
"They lacked the terms students, education, academics and all the vocabulary you would expect to hear when talking about the future of a school district," Bachli said. "I heard a lot about the town's survival, the town's businesses and loss of jobs ... when do we talk about the kids? The solvency of any town should not be placed on the back of an elementary school."
Bachli ended by saying he felt the town of Adams took on a threatening tone at the last forum and that "the School Committee should not be threatened into a decision."
Adams Town Administrator Tony Mazzucco took to the microphone and said he was not trying to be threatening but realistic. With Adams nearing its levy ceiling, it will not be able to fund education.
"The money is just not there. … In less than 10 years we are tapped out. That means by law we cannot raise any more taxes," he said. "Once we are there we are done: no more money for school, close the Council on Aging, close the library. All that will happen so if we were talking about business not mattering if we had the economy we wanted, we would not be in this situation."
Mazzucco agreed with an earlier statement that Cheshire pays more per pupil than Adams because it is relatively more wealthy than Adams, but Adams brings in more state revenue because it has more low-income families and is the poorer community.
He said he did not think it was fair that in a regional agreement, Adams is left with no public schools in its borders while Cheshire has two.
"That is not parochial. We are just trying to look at the reality and equity for the district, and this would leave Adams with zero schools," he said. "I would think they teach some sharing at the elementary school level and teach good manners and how to work with people. Two public schools in Cheshire and none in Adams is not fair."
Ciskowski hit back and said Cheshire, too, struggles with finances but chooses to operate within their means. Cheshire does not have a library to close because it is in a room in its aging town hall and the Cheshire Police force does not operate full time.
"One of the reasons they are poor is because any money that they had they spent on things that we don’t have. We lead a very frugal life in Cheshire," he said.
"When Adams cries poor with all of the services and facilities that they have, it reminds me of a story — there is an orphan that wants you to feel bad for him and you started to feel bad for him until you realize he killed his parents. That's what Adams did with their money."
A number of Cheshire parents also spoke out at the meeting, sharing their experience with the school.
"As relatively new parents with a child in the school system, I can't express the happiness gratitude we feel toward staff," parent Scott Campbell said. "It has been a great experience for our family. We made this our home and we can’t think of a better place to establish roots for our child."
"The education they received here was excellent, they had plenty of room in the classrooms and they were given the individual attention they really needed," parent Chris Megaro said. "They always enjoyed their time at Cheshire and they felt welcomed and at home."
Third-grade Plunkett teacher Beth Bourdon said she did have concerns about space at Cheshire, but affirmed that no matter which school closes, teachers will continue to put students first.
"I am really looking forward to working with our Cheshire colleagues, and we think it is going to be wonderful," she said. "I am looking forward to working with Cheshire parents because we are all about education and that's why we are here."
"Every teacher that works in this district works hard and ... whatever issues we are all facing we need to come together as a solid community."
The School Committee will vote on closing a school Thursday, March 2.
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.
Your Comments
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
No Comments
Cheshire Tag Sale and Bazaar
CHESHIRE, Mass. — The Cheshire Community Association (CCA) announced the return of the Cheshire Community Tag Sale and Bazaar for its second year.
Scheduled for Saturday, May 11, 2024, from 9 AM to 1 PM, the event offers a day of treasure hunting, local craftsmanship, and treats at the Cheshire Community House located at 191 Church St, Cheshire.
Attendees can explore a variety of offerings, including handmade crafts, antiques, collectibles, and food options. The hot food truck, operated by the Berkshire Lodge of Masons AF & AM, will be stationed in the courtyard, serving up treats throughout the event.
One of the highlights of this year's event is the fundraising raffle, with all proceeds set to benefit the Cheshire Food Pantry. Participants can purchase raffle tickets for a chance to win prizes, supporting a worthy cause that serves the local community.
Registration for vendors interested in participating in the bazaar is currently open, with fees ranging from $10 to $30. Cheshire residents looking to showcase their items from home can have their locations advertised on the event map for a fee of $10. The deadline for registration is set for Friday, April 26, 2024.
Registration forms can be obtained from various locations across Cheshire, including A to Z Printing, Cheshire Community House, Cheshire Library, Cheshire Glassworks, Cheshire Senior Center, the Cheshire Community Association Facebook page, and the Cheshire Town website.
For more information about the event, including vendor registration and sponsorship opportunities, interested parties are encouraged to contact Jenny Gadbois at (413) 841-0844 or via email at jlgadbois@icloud.com.
Taylor Garabedian scored a team-high 22 points and grabbed five rebounds, and Abby Scialabba scored 16 points for the ‘Canes, who got 16 points, nine rebounds and four assists from Ashlyn Lesure. click for more
On Saturday afternoon at Lowell’s Tsongas Center, the Hurricanes will take aim at Division 5 State Championships in girls and boys basketball. click for more
Pittsfield High's Matt Dupuis and Lee's Bella Kotek Sunday completed a Berkshire County sweep at the State Bowling Championships at Bowlero.
click for more
Emily Holian’s strike to open the 10th frame of the Wildcats’ second game against Worcester Tech all but assured Lee a team title at Bowlero Chicopee.
click for more
Hoosac struggled to get into rhythm on the offensive end until Joey McGovern got the 3-ball working. McGovern finished the game with 21 points including a triple in the fourth quarter that cemented him in the record books. It took him nearly the whole game but he was able to join the 1,000-point... click for more
Pittsfield High's Eliza Mullen won state title and in the giant slalom and slalom, winning the former discipline by 1.6 seconds and the latter by nearly 2.7 seconds.
click for more