Letter: Homeless Housing in MCLA Dorm is NOT the Solution

Letter to the EditorPrint Story | Email Story

To the Editor:

Initially, I was not against the idea of MCLA's president, Jamie Birge, announcing plans to open a currently empty dorm building for housing homeless families, however, the more I've talked with neighbors and friends, the more I believe it's a horrible idea.

As a direct neighbor to MCLA, I didn't have a problem with the Boardman Block being used for people in recovery once I learned about the support services provided (even though I don't believe it's an ideal companion to the students that work and live nearby and that MCLA should have had the vision to acquire it for themselves for future needs/expansion).

This current plan reinforces my long held belief that Mr. Birge has no vision for MCLA and, as a part-time resident of New Hampshire, he's not at all invested in the future of MCLA or North Adams. I question whether or not Mr. Birge has aggressively pursued all recruitment and retention opportunities and identified organizational changes to increase student admissions. That must be his No. 1 priority and I'm incredibly skeptical that it is.

If the homeless situation in North Adams is such that additional housing is needed then I am all for considering every option. However, if the homeless families would be relocated from outside the city, then I think Mr. Birge is simply looking for "easy" money. Unless all efforts are made to increase the shrinking admissions, Mr. Birge's plan seems no different than when North Adams slumlords placed newspaper ads in Troy, N.Y., years ago offering free TVs to Section 8 renters if they relocated to one of their North Adams units.


In the years since Mr. Birge has been MCLA's president, I've failed to see any evidence of passion or vision on his part to strengthen or expand the college's future legacy. Fault lies not only with him, but also with the members of the board of directors and selection committee. It's their responsibility to hold Mr. Birge accountable and to have made passion and vision for the college (and the city) top criteria for the job. It appears they've failed to do either.

By establishing a significant homeless population two blocks away from the new recovery housing, Mr. Birge would practically guarantee a continued decline in admissions and risk the future closure of the college altogether.

Again, I am in full support of identifying safe and comfortable housing for our local homeless population if that is an actual need. Such a proposal should not be situated on the campus of an already struggling college and should not be the solution for other communities' failure to address their own housing needs. If it is a local issue, then city residents should be made aware of it because I've yet to speak with any of my friends living all around the downtown area that have seen or know of a single homeless person in North Adams.

MCLA is a huge asset to the city, the county, and the state and should be treated as such. If Mr. Birge has not been able to successfully address the college's declining admissions then perhaps it's time for the fresh perspective of new leadership.

Kurt Kolok
North Adams, Mass.

 

 

 


Tags: homeless,   

If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.

McCann Making Progress Toward MCAS Targets

By Jack GuerinoiBerkshires Staff

NORTH ADAMS, Mass. — McCann Tech Principal Justin Kratz told the Northern Berkshire Vocational Regional School District School Committee last week that because the school is making substantial progress toward its 2026 MCAS targets, there will be no Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE) intervention.

"So long story short, we are not on DESE's radar for MCAS performance," he said. "At the end of the day, that is what is what we are after."

Kratz said McCann scored "a ton" of points, showing growth in most categories. He said they earned 75 percent of total possible points for all students and 83 percent of all possible points for lowest-performing students.

Kratz noted that DESE tends to change targets and formulas every year. But he drew attention to the year 2025, when a passing MCAS score was no longer a graduation requirement. In 2025, McCann received 33 percent of the possible points and 7 percent for the lowest-performing students. This equaled a score of 20 percent.

"That was the year where everything went off the cliff," he said. "We didn't do very well. This year was 79 percent, and that is knocking it out of the park. ... If we followed up with another 20, we would have been in rough water."

Kratz added this drop was typical across the state, saying he assumed students just took the test less seriously. He wanted to demonstrate how the scores and targets are "reshuffled" and gave a closer look at English scores over the years.

In 2024, the school had a target of 499.3 (average scaled score). The school scored 500.4. In 2025, McCann's new target was 502.5, but McCann scored 485.6. McCann's 2026 target was 487.7, and they scored 486.8.

Kratz said McCann is not scoring as high as they were in 2024, but they are getting more points. He said sometimes the scores needed to be taken with a "grain of salt."

He underlined that although MCAS is important in a vocational education, it only represents half of what a student does in a given school year. 

"There is no MCAS for 50 percent of their time here, which is their trade area," Kratz said. "They [DESE] don't assess that ... so this one little pocket is important, but it doesn't show the entire picture of a student."

Kratz moved from what he called the "good" section of his presentation to the "awesome." He said McCann was recognized as one of 55 schools that drastically improved chronic absenteeism by at least 5 percentage points. He said the school received a letter from DESE congratulating them that included a survey that asked how the school did it.

"It was a nice letter, but we kind of laughed and asked, 'What did we do?' " he said. "I say that sort of tongue-in-cheek because we didn't do any sort of targeted attendance improvement initiative."

He said the more he thought about it, the more he attributed the change to standardized grading and improving the school environment physically and culturally.  

"We didn't do all that wanting to improve attendance. We did it because we wanted to create more equity, and ... I think that is a byproduct of that," Kratz said. "Kids are more likely to want to go to school if that 62 they got on a test does not bury them for the rest of the year. They know they can dig their way out of it. And they are more likely to go to school if the building is a little brighter when they walk in in the morning."

Also, the importance of attendance is baked into the vocational school experience.

View Full Story

More North Adams Stories