This is the first in a series of columns on wind power development in the Berkshires. Next week: Which Gov. Romney do we believe?
“He that troubleth his own house shall inherit the wind.â€
— Proverbs 11:29
Ten years ago, on the cover of Windpower Monthly, an international organ of the windpower community, appeared a full-color photograph of a bloody vulture cut in half by a windmill blade at a site in Tarifa, Spain. The journal editors explained the seriousness of their choice: “The decision to print this month’s cover ... will have a significant impact, both on the world of wind power and elsewhere ... There is a real problem with bird deaths at Tarifa. It cannot be kept quiet and it will not go away of its own accord ... There are parallels between the problems of raptors in the Altamont Pass [a California windpower site] and the Tarifa controversy.â€
The Altamont Pass windpower project, a 50-square-mile site in the Diablo Mountains between San Francisco and the agricultural Central Valley, was one of our country’s first, and it has been producing clean, renewable electricity for 20 years. But also, for 20 years, its huge fiberglass blades on more than 4,000 windmills, have been chopping up tens of thousands of birds, including migratory geese and ducks, raptors like red-tail hawks and owls and the world’s highest density of nesting golden eagles. The windmills pass along an international migratory bird route under government regulation, which puts the windpower companies at risk of federal prosecution.
But despite over 20 years of studying this problem, the companies, environmental groups and the government have made very little progress in finding a remedy, and the size of the body count at Altamont remains at about 5,000 birds a year. One ecologist put it succinctly: “They didn’t realize it at the time, but it was just a really bad place to build a wind farm.†(USA Today, 1/2005)
This colossal lack of planning and foresight, with such catastrophic results, is an example we can’t ignore here in the Berkshires, because very soon our own house is going to be troubled on the question of windpower sites: After opposing a windmill project in Nantucket Sound following pressure from local groups there, Gov. Mitt Romney, in early December, gave his support to windmill projects in Franklin and Berkshire counties — the Hoosac Wind Project — in which European-based enXco Company plans to build 20 windmills in Florida and Monroe, each 340 feet tall, on two of our most visible mountain tops.
A second company, Berkshire Wind Power LLC, is poised to build 10 turbines in Hancock. Additional windpower sites are being planned by the Romney administration for Brodie Mountain and are being proposed for Berlin and Lenox mountains and more on the Hoosac range. Romney’s secretary of environmental affairs has approved every inland windpower project without asking for a complete review by environmental experts and is not considering setting up a statewide planning process for choosing the sites. (www.GreenBerkshires.org).
Killing birds is not the only problem to be resolved in siting windpower projects. Other major dilemmas are that windpower hasn’t yet proven to be viable economically for a region; it is intermittent and not readily storable, and it is land intensive and destructive to the environment during and after it is built.
But using mountain tops and the sky for gathering the wind is a question that has blood on it: Our mountain ranges are primary migratory routes for golden eagles, hawks, bald eagles — and generations of bats. Our communities are under pressure from the Romney administration and international power companies to accept these projects, but we need to talk first. Remember Altamont.
Tela Zasloff, a writer living in Williamstown, frequently writes on environmental issues for The Advocate. Reader response is welcome via e-mail, news@advocateweekly.com, fax, 664-7900, or mail, the Advocate, 100 Main St., North Adams MA 01247.
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.
Your Comments
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
No Comments
Pittsfield Families Frustrated Over Unreleased PHS Report, Herberg Slur Incident
By Brittany PolitoiBerkshires Staff
PITTSFIELD, Mass. — Parents are expressing their frustration with hate speech, bullying, and staff misconduct, which they said happens in Pittsfield schools.
Community members and some elected officials have consistently advocated for the release of the redacted Pittsfield High School investigation report, and a teacher being placed on leave for allegedly repeating racist and homophobic slurs sparked a community conversation about how Pittsfield Public Schools can address injustices.
The district's human resources director detailed the investigation processes during last week's School Committee meeting.
"People are angry. They feel like when they spoke up about Morningside School, it was closed anyway. They feel like they speak up about the PHS report, and that's just kind of getting shoved under the rug," resident Brenda Coddington said during public comment.
"I mean, when do people who actually voted for all of you, by the way, when does their voice and opinion count and matter? Because you can sit up here all day long and say that it does, but your actions, or rather lack of action, speak volumes."
Three administrators and two teachers, past and present, were investigated by Bulkley Richardson and Gelinas LLP for a range of allegations that surfaced or re-surfaced at the end of 2024 after Pittsfield High's former dean of students was arrested and charged by the U.S. Attorney's Office for allegedly conspiring to traffic large quantities of cocaine in Western Massachusetts.
Executive summaries were released that concluded the claims of inappropriate conduct between teachers and students were "unsupported." Ward 7 Councilor Katherine Moody countered one of the unsupported determinations, writing on Facebook last week that she knows one person can conclude with confidence and a court case that pictures of the staff member's genitalia was sent to minors.
"During this investigation, we sought to determine the validity of allegations about PHS Administrator #2 sharing a photograph of female genitalia with PHS students on her Snapchat account," the final executive summary reads.
Brooke Harrington scored four goals, and Abigail Rodhouse had a hat trick as Wahconah won its second straight Western Mass title and the rubber match against the Mounties in the third one-goal game between the teams this spring. click for more
Mount Greylock Regional School seventh-grader Scarlett Foley Sunday beat two opponents from Division 2 Longmeadow to capture the Western Mass Tennis Individuals Championship. click for more
Qwanell Bradley scored 33 points, and Adan Wicks added 29 as the Hoosac Valley boys basketball team won a Division 5 State Championship on Sunday. click for more
Adan Wicks scored 38 points, and the eighth-seeded Hoosac Valley basketball team Saturday rallied from a nine-point first-half deficit to earn a 76-67 win over top-seeded Drury in the Division 5 State Quarter-Finals. click for more