No Murder Indictment in North Adams Stabbing

Staff reportsiBerkshires
Print Story | Email Story
PITTSFIELD, Mass. — A Berkshire County grand jury has declined to indict a New York man in the stabbing death of Daniel J. Walters, 24, of North Adams. It did, however, return indictments on a variety of charges against him and seven others connected to circumstances surrounding the death.

The grand jury heard two days of testimony from witnesses and police officers before voting not to charge Ronnell Garmie, 19, of the Bronx, N.Y., for either murder or manslaughter. It returned no bills on both indictments considered.

Garmie allegedly stabbed Walters during a scuffle at a residence in Wheel Estates Mobile Home Park in North Adams on Aug. 20. Walters, said police, was trying to steal cocaine from Garmie.

According to the three-month investigation, Walters, his mother, Constance Pratt, and his girlfriend, Monique M. Rock, drove to Tina Senecal's mobile home on Navajo Drive in the early hours of Aug. 20 with a plan to steal a quantity of cocaine from Garmie. Investigators say Senecal was allowing Garmie to stay at the mobile home and use it as a base for his alleged cocaine distribution.

Walters was stabbed during the attempted heist; Garmie allegedly fled the scene. He was arrested the next morning at his mother's home in the Bronx.

Garmie, also known as "Clue," was arraigned on one count of murder in Northern Berkshire District Court on Sept. 10. However, the grand jury declined to indict him on that charge, which would have moved it to Superior Court.

He was indicted drug charges and was arraigned Monday afternoon in Berkshire Superior Court on single counts of trafficking in cocaine and conspiracy to violate drug laws (distribution of cocaine). Not-guilty pleas were entered on his behalf and Judge John A. Agostini ordered him held at the Berkshire County House of Correction on $100,000 bail.

Police say Garmie had more than 28 grams of cocaine in his possession on Aug. 20. It is also alleged that he conspired with other others to sell cocaine in North Adams between Aug. 1 and Aug. 20. 

Senecal, 52, was indicted on single counts of trafficking in cocaine, conspiracy to violate drug laws (distribution of cocaine) and furnishing misleading information to a police officer. She is scheduled to be arraigned on Dec. 29.

Pratt, 44, also known as Constance Winnie, of Williamstown and Rock, of North Adams, were both indicted on single counts each of attempting to commit a crime (larceny from a person) and furnishing misleading information to a police officer.

Police say the two gave false information to officers during the initial stages of the investigation. They also are scheduled to be arraigned in Superior Court on Dec. 29.
 
Four others were also indicted on charges of aiding Garmie or being involved in drug trafficking.

Shelley L. Nichlen, 28, of North Adams, also known as Michele Nichlen and as "Sassy," and Wayne A. Senecal Jr., 22, of North Adams (who authorities say is not related to Tina Senecal) were each indicted on single counts of furnishing misleading information to a police officer. Police say the pair both helped Garmie after he allegedly fled the scene and then misled police investigators.

Nichlen is scheduled to be arraigned on Dec. 30 and Senecal on Jan. 5, both in Superior Court.
 
Also indicted were Brenda L. Blasi, 40, and Kathleen Lear, 46, also known as Catherine Lear, both of North Adams on single counts each of conspiracy to violate drug laws (distribution of cocaine). Authorities say Blasi and Lear prepared and delivered cocaine for Garmie as well as drumming up new customers.

Blasi is to be arraigned on Dec. 29 in Superior Court and Lear on Dec. 30

The investigation was conducted by state police detectives assigned to the district attorney's office, who were aided by members of the North Adams Police Department.

Information supplied by the district attorney's office.
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.

Veteran Spotlight: Army Sgt. John Magnarelli

By Wayne SoaresSpecial to iBerkshires
PLYMOUTH, Mass. — John Magnarelli served his country in the Army's 82nd Airborne Division and the 11th Armored Cavalry Regiment in Vietnam from May 4, 1969, to April 10, 1970, as a sergeant. 
 
He grew up in North Quincy and was drafted into the Army on Aug. 12, 1968. 
 
"I had been working in a factory, Mathewson Machine Works, as a drill press operator since I graduated high school. It was a solid job and I had fallen into a comfortable routine," he said. "That morning, I left home with my dad, who drove me to the South Boston Army Base, where all new recruits were processed into service. There was no big send off — he just dropped me off on his way to work. He shook my hand and said, 'good luck and stay safe.'"
 
He would do his basic training at Fort Jackson, S.C., which was built in 1917 and named after President Andrew Jackson. 
 
"It was like a city — 20,000 people, 2,500 buildings and 50 firing ranges on 82 square miles," he said. "I learned one thing very quickly, that you never refer to your rifle as a gun. That would earn you the ire of the drill sergeant and typically involve a great deal of running." 
 
He continued proudly, "after never having fired a gun in my life, I received my marksmanship badge at the expert level."
 
He was assigned to Fort Benning, Ga., for Combat Leadership School then sent to Vietnam.
 
View Full Story

More North Adams Stories