Spruces Owners Drop Case Against Williamstown, State

By Andy McKeeveriBerkshires Staff
Print Story | Email Story
WILLIAMSTOWN, Mass. — The owners of the Spruces Mobile Home Park have withdrawn their lawsuit against the town, state and residents.

According to Town Manager Peter Fohlin, the Aug. 9 hearing in Berkshire Superior Court has been canceled after Morgan Management dropped the case at the request of the town.

"The town and the residents of the Spruces have expended every effort to recover every home possible and to remove or secure those that are uninhabitable. These diligent efforts continue to effectively accomplish virtually everything meaningful requested in the motion for injunctive relief," Fohlin said in an email on Tuesday. "It would not be in the best interests of the Spruces residents to further pursue resolution in court."

Tropical Storm Irene ravaged the park last August and left some 300 residents homeless. Over the following months, residents slowly returned to the park as their homes were certified as habitable while others moved elsewhere. A majority of the park's 226 mobile homes could not be reoccupied.

The situation triggered heated debates between the town and the park's owners — each pointing the finger at one another as to why residents were unable to return to their homes. Even Gov. Deval Patrick called on both Morgan Management and the Federal Emergency Management Agency to "step up" and resolve the problems.

The company filed an injunction last November against the town, state attorney general's office and Spruces residents to bring the matter into court, which was expected to explicitly lay out the responsibilities of each party.

Morgan Management requested eight resolutions: halt further infrastructure work until a plan for the park's future was developed, residents 30 days to state their intentions, allow the company to take steps to consolidate the park, force residents living in uninhabitable homes out, have residents remove abandoned trailers in 30 days, reprieve from state pressures to take immediate action, have residents remove "non-ordinary trash" and any other order that would help the situation.

However, the case was delayed multiple times with the latest expected court date of Aug. 9. Now most of the items are no longer issues, according to Fohlin. As for the future of the park, Fohlin said the town has developed "a constructive and respectful relationship" with the owners to work out solutions together.

"The town and Morgan Management, along with the hold of the mortgage on The Spruces, have been in continuous good faith discussions about the future of the park and its residents," Fohlin said. "Our shared goal is safe, sanitary and secure housing out of harm's way and without worry for residents who continue to live in the Spruces or have been displaced by Tropical Storm Irene."

With the withdrawal, Fohlin said both the town and the company can devote more resources to the future rather than "costly litigation."

Related Stories
Spruces Mobile Home Park Court Case Continued Again
WILLIAMSTOWN - 04-13-2012 - The case was originally scheduled to go to court on Dec. 6, 2011. It was pushed back to Dec. 13, 2011, delayed again...
FEMA Distributes $3.6M to Spruces Residents
WILLIAMSTOWN - 03-27-2012 - "We are actively working with over 200 residents of the park. There are many who want to return to Williamstown if they...

Spruces Court Case Continued While Settlement Is...
WILLIAMSTOWN - 01-18-2012 - According to court documents on Jan. 4, the parties agreed to again delay the hearing.

Spruces Occupancy Projections Continue to Dwindle
WILLIAMSTOWN - 01-10-2012 - "We do not, however, have any indication of any additional trailers that people intend to occupy beyond 64." —...

Williamstown Expects Third of Spruces Homes Restored
WILLIAMSTOWN - 12-14-2011 - "I think it is doubtful that we reach 75, which is a third of the trailers that were there before [Tropical Storm]...
Spruces Owners Lay Out Demands
WILLIAMSTOWN - 11-28-2011 - "If these orders go through they will define who will stay and who will go." — Peter Fohlin
Spruces Owners Sue Williamstown, State
WILLIAMSTOWN - 11-15-2011 - "I'd rather see the attorney general use her hammer to deal with it rather than us using our fly swatter." Peter Fohlin

FEMA Leaves Spruces Residents Up In The Air
WILLIAMSTOWN - 09-12-2011 - "They did what they had to do and we now know we have a safe home." — Helen Leavens
Latest Update on Spruces Mobile Home Park Conditions
WILLIAMSTOWN - 09-07-2011 - The town's health inspector is continuing to update the conditions of mobile homes in the park.
Spruces Residents Prod Board of Health For Answers
WILLIAMSTOWN - 09-07-2011 - "It does not say you cannot get your stuff. It does not mean you have to tear it down. It means you cannot live there."...
Patrick Calls for 'Swift' Response for Spruces...
WILLIAMSTOWN - 09-01-2011 - "I think FEMA will step up. I think they understand their responsibility." — Deval Patrick
Disaster Center Set Up; Spruces Park Being Assessed
WILLIAMSTOWN - 08-31-2011 - Gov. Deval Patrick's office confirmed Wednesday that he will tour some of the damage in Williamstown late Thursday...
Williamstown Rules Spruces 'Uninhabitable'
WILLIAMSTOWN - 08-29-2011 - "All of the [226] homes are conditionally uninhabitable." — Peter Fohlin
Four Rescued By Boat From Spruces
WILLIAMSTOWN - 08-28-2011 - "As far as I know everybody is out of there." — Fire Chief Craig Pedercini

Tags: demolition,   Irene,   lawsuit,   Spruces,   

iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue; please keep comments focused on the issues and not on personalities. Profanity, obscenity, racist language and harassment are not allowed. iBerkshires reserves the right to ban commenters or remove commenting on any article at any time. Concerns may be sent to info@iberkshires.com.

iBerkshires.com Text Ads

Crisp by Hot Tomatoes

Beer + Pizza = Love! Located at Bright Ideas Brewing Co 111 Mass MoCa Way, N.Adams (413)346-4460


Bob's Camper & RV

Summer SALE! Hot Deals you don't want to miss out on. Click to view Inventory. (413)458-3093


Tavern at the

Healthy pub style food, weekend entertainment, beautiful views, banquets. Pittsfield 413-448-9009


Support Local News

We show up at hurricanes, budget meetings, high school games, accidents, fires and community events. We show up at celebrations and tragedies and everything in between. We show up so our readers can learn about pivotal events that affect their communities and their lives.

How important is local news to you? You can support independent, unbiased journalism and help iBerkshires grow for as a little as the cost of a cup of coffee a week.

Recent Stories