On Monday Police released the video of the incident in which Shugrue says it is clear that the doorman asked the shooting victim for identification.
PITTSFIELD, Mass. — Instead of having her liquor license suspended for five days, Methuselah owner Yuki Cohen is donating the profits from those days to a local non-profit.
Methuselah was called before the Licensing Board to answer to an incident on Nov. 25, 2016, when a 17-year-old was drinking at the bar and then was shot moments after right outside the door.
The Licensing Board agreed on Monday to stay a license suspension for a year, meaning if there are any violations in the next year the suspension is automatically imposed, and to accept her offer to donate the profits for those five days to a non-profit.
"In lieu of closing, my client is willing to donate her profit, her income, during a period you suggest to underage drinking [prevention] or any non-profit organization so that the employees continue to work so we don't harm them in the process," attorney Timothy Shugrue said.
"I know it is unique."
Shugrue's proposal came right as the board was looking to suspend the bar's license anywhere from three days to seven days. The issue centered on the underage drinking incident that board member Richard Stockwell compared to an incident at Lach's Lounge a year ago in which that bar faced a seven-day suspension.
"I think what happened at Methuselah, unfortunately, mirrors exactly what happened at Lach's Lounge. There was a violation at the bar. The gentleman left the bar. It was outside on city property where both of these individuals were shot," Stockwell said.
"I have a very strong feeling that this board cannot treat North Street, the upscale bars on North Street, differently than the bars on Wahconah Street, Tyler Street, or Madison, or Onota."
James Dominguez was inside Lach's on Jan. 23, 2016; when he left, he was shot and killed in the parking lot. Responding officers found patrons who were heavily intoxicated — a violation of overserving. The Licensing Board issued the seven-day suspension as well as forced the bar to close at midnight for two months.
That hearing also included the mayor issuing a statement arguing for the board to "deliver a strong message."
At Methuselah, a 17-year-old man was drinking at Methuselah and upon leaving, he was shot outside.
But Board member Thomas Campoli doesn't see the two incidents as being the same. It was just a few months before the Lach's suspension that its owners were brought before the boardfor a separate incident. In that case, in October 2015, an altercation occurred inside the bar and one man left and ended up shooting someone outside. A firearm was also passed between individuals in the bar and the police say a bartender misled them about it.
"That came on the heels of a much more troubling incident at Lachs," Campoli said.
Methuselah hasn't been perfect, however, and has gone before the Licensing Board in the past for overcrowding. Then the state Alcoholic Beverages Control Commission issued a one-day suspension to Methuselah's license.
But, on Monday there was nobody looking to send any strong messages about illegal activity. Instead, downtown business merchants and the president of Downtown Pittsfield Inc. argued the importance of the Methuselah to North Street's business growth.
"To us, this is a strategically important business," said Downtown Pittsfield Inc. President Jesse Cook-Dubin.
Cook-Dubin went on to say that the long-term efforts to revitalize the city's downtown depends on entrepreneurs taking risks to open businesses in struggling blocks. On both sides of Methuselah, the blocks are filled with struggling businesses rotating in and out. But "this block is becoming one of those strong blocks."
He was worried about the "stigma" caused by a suspension and the ultimate loss of business Cohen would possibly see. He added that the bar is where his company and other companies bring young professionals they are trying to recruit.
"This is a good citizen in our community, not just Mrs. Cohen but this whole operation," Cook-Dubin said.
Steven Valenti, owner of Steven Valenti's Clothing for Men, echoed those sentiments and he was joined by a few other downtown business people. Meanwhile, David Hall of the Rotary Club praised Cohen for her community work that includes donations each year for a raffle the club uses to raise money to send children to summer camps.
"We depend on the good businesses in our community for these donations," Hall said.
Despite how good of a community partner Cohen is, the board still felt that it needed to treat the bar fairly compared to other incidents such as at Johnny's Beach Club, Lach's Lounge, and Chameleons. Campoli, however, said all of those incidents — minus the second at Lach's Lounge — had started from altercations inside the establishments and the bars had previous violations.
"It is obvious there is no nexus between the shooting and anything that happened inside of the bar," Campoli said.
In Methuselah's case, there was no altercation inside the bar. Further, Methuselah argued it had done everything it could to prevent a violation. The 17-year-old who was shot was described as looking older than his age and had presented doorman Shane Tatro an identification card. Police found a Massachusetts license in the victim's pocket which had him listed as being age 25.
Tatro, however, said that he remembered it being a Connecticut license and the man was 35. But, Shugrue said maybe it was, in fact, the license officers found. Nonetheless, between facial hair and tattoos, the man allegedly didn't look underage and Tatro said he checked the photo, the birthdate, and the name.
"He didn't set off any alarms," Tatro said of the identification.
Board member Diane Pero, however, looked at the photos of the man and at the identification and said there are a number of inconsistencies in the photo on the license found and the photos of the victim. Further, she said there are signs in the photo of the victim that indicate he may not have been over the age of 21.
Despite the inconsistency in statements and consideration whether or not it was an honest mistake, it is still a violation. For that, the board agreed it needed to take some action.
Pero said because of the actions the board took against others in similar situations, she couldn't "look the other way" in this case. She advocated for a suspension. Board member Dana Doyle then motioned for a three-day suspension but that failed to get a second. Stockwell ultimately motioned for Shugrue's suggestion, which was adopted by the board.
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue; please keep comments focused on the issues and not on personalities. Profanity, obscenity, racist language and harassment are not allowed. iBerkshires reserves the right to ban commenters or remove commenting on any article at any time. Concerns may be sent to firstname.lastname@example.org.
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
Comments are closed for this article. If you would like to contribute information on this article, e-mail us at info@iBerkshires.com
Gotta Dance, Gotta Sing: There's Both This Week on Local Stages
By Grace LichtensteinGuest Column
Downtown Pittsfield Third Thursdays — TL Collective
Each third Thursday of the month, streets are closed in downtown Pittsfield and all kinds of music rocks the city. Featured June 20 at 6 p.m. in the Dance Zone at the north end of the street festival is TL Collective, the athletic, family-friendly contemporary and hip-hop moves of Micaela Taylor's company. The group performs an evening length work "Drift." The aim, according to organizers, is to "demonstrate an individual's ever-changing relationship to self while exposing a personal season of self-growth."
You can find the dance zone near the corner of Bradford and North Streets in front of St. Joseph’s Church. This program is a presentation of the Berkshires stalwart Jacob's Pillow.
Ballet BC is coming to Jacob's Pillow this week.
At the Pillow's expansive home in Becket, the featured company in the Ted Shawn Theater this week is Ballet BC, which is celebrating 10 years under the innovative leadership of artistic director and former company member Emily Molnar.
"Truly contemporary" is how one reviewer described the Vancouver-based troupe. On the bill this week is Molnar's most recent work "To this day," along with the U.S. premiere of "Bedroom Folk." The latter work originated with the Nederlands Dans Theater and was created by Israeli collaborators Sharon Eyal and Gai Behar, among others.
This program runs Wednesday, June 19, through Sunday, June 23, at 8 p.m., with matinees on Saturday and Sunday in addition to evenings.
The design efforts to restore the Springside Pond is entering the permitting phase.
Parks and Open Spaces Manager Jim McGrath updated the Parks Commission on Tuesday about the progress and said the city will be seeking permits from the Conservation Commission in the coming weeks. However, the... click for more
Two newly hired firefighters resigned after it was found they had falsely claimed residency to get a boost in the Civil Service exam.
The Civil Service Commission called for an investigation into the matter after a bypass appeal was filed late last fall. Justin Brady had taken the exam but did... click for more
The state hopes to see more renewable energy from solar and thus incentives solar development. However, the way the programs are currently established, the solar often comes at the expense of cutting trees.
"We have perverse incentives for solar. It is cheaper for a developer to come in and cut... click for more
Thanks to a $900,000 state grant, Herberg Middle School is poised to vastly improve the academics in the building.
Herberg has had low scores on state assessments leading it into "turnaround status" and Principal Martin McEvoy and Assistant Principal for Teaching and Learning Lisa Lesser crafted... click for more
Christian Womble tossed a complete-game with 10 strikeouts and scored the first run, and Anton Lazits had a solo home run to lead Taconic to a 5-1 win over Wahconah in the Western Mass Division 3 championship at UMass on Saturday. click for more
When Brittany Sullivan lost her sister, her life spiraled out of control.
"When I was 14 years old, my sister died suddenly in a car accident. This sent me into a downward spiral that led me to drinking, smoking, and dipping into opioids, which eventually got me kicked out of my home at 17.... click for more