PITTSFIELD, Mass. — The Berkshire Museum has released its financial reports in an effort to prove that its controversial sale of artworks was needed to keep the institution open.
The museum posted its independent audit, its federal tax statement Form 990, the Massachusetts state tax statement required as a non-profit, and annual filing for charitable organizations in New York State, which is filed with registration to solicit donations from New York.
"These documents reinforce the conclusions of both the Museum's Board of Trustees and the Office of the Attorney General about the dire financial situation of the museum, including annual operating deficits of more than $1 million that would, eventually, force the museum to close its doors," according to the press release that accompanied the documents.
Museum officials have contended that the century-old entity has faced a structural operating deficit each year to the tune of $1.15 million. The 2017 audit released by the museum and done independently by Adelson & Company PC shows that continued to be the case in 2017.
The audit shows the museum took in $1,482,412 for operational revenues -- that includes such things as fundraising, admissions, special events, and facility rentals. At the same time, the expenses in 2017 were $2,808,622. That left a gap of $1,272,558 that was pulled from its long-term investments.
Those investments had only brought in $613,260 last year, meaning the starting balance in the next fiscal year was $659,298 less. The museum said it has watched its endowment, intended to offset operating costs through its annual returns, and the Keep Crane Fund dwindle for the last decade.
The audit shows the museum's total assets dropping from $19,730, 208 in 2016 to $18,940,743 in 2017.
It was those trends that led the board of trustees to launch a plan to dramatically shake up the museum. It announced its "new vision" last year, which included a full revamping of the exhibits and the museum itself. That plan also called to bolster the endowment for years to come.
That vision, however, sparked controversy because it included the sale of some 40 pieces from the museum's collection. Lawsuits, condemnation from other museum directors, and an investigation was launched by Attorney General Maura Healey.
But after the attorney general dug into the numbers, she worked a deal with the Supreme Judicial Court to allow for the sales but restricted it to $55 million worth.
The greatest contention was over the sale of "Shuffleton's Barbershop," a Norman Rockwell work donated to the museum by the artist himself. Rockwell's family filed suit against the museum but agreed to the AGO's settlement. The piece was purchased by George Lucas for an undisclosed price for his under-construction Los Angeles museum with the condition it be exhibited locally and within Massachusetts for a period of time. It's currently on display at the Norman Rockwell Museum in Stockbridge.
After 13 pieces were sold, the museum announced another nine pieces were heading to auction as it worked toward hitting the $55 million mark.
But the outrage hasn't halted. The group Save The Art has scheduled a rally outside of the museum in protest of the sale on Saturday. The rally comes on the anniversary of the museum's announcement of the "new vision" and the group is still calling on the museum to halt any further deaccessioning.
"With $47 million now in the bank, the board cannot claim that it needs to further strip away the collection to keep its doors open," Save the Art contends. "It should not sacrifice the important remaining works by great artists such as Bierstadt, Moran, and Calder just to reach an arbitrary $55 million goal with no specific plan."
Prior to the museum making its financial statements public, Save the Art called on the museum to release its financial information.
"It is also vital for the board to provide information so the community can accurately assess the situation. There are many unanswered questions as to why the board originally decided that this unpopular decision to sell off its art was necessary. The public has a right to know the museum's actual financial situation and whether its contract with Sotheby's had any impact on their resistance to widespread calls to take a pause in the sales," Save the Art wrote.
Museum officials said they had given the financial statements directly to The Berkshire Eagle but the newspaper hadn't published the information.
"Last year, we provided The Berkshire Eagle a detailed briefing on the museum's finances. This year, and more than two weeks ago, continuing in the spirit of transparency, the Berkshire Museum's board and staff directly provided these documents to The Berkshire Eagle along with an interview with key members of the Finance Committee of the Board of Trustees," the museum wrote.
"However, because this information has not yet been released or reported on, today [Tuesday] we are making those same documents available directly to the public on the museum's website."
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue; please keep comments focused on the issues and not on personalities. Profanity, obscenity, racist language and harassment are not allowed. iBerkshires reserves the right to ban commenters or remove commenting on any article at any time. Concerns may be sent to firstname.lastname@example.org.
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
Pou's No-Hitter Lifts Force 12U to Dalton CRA Title
By Rick DuteauiBerkshires.com Sports
DALTON, Mass - Sunday’s performance was exactly the sort of thing that Berkshire Force 12U coach Jess Glebus hoped for, at exactly the right time. Just days ahead of a big trip to Florida to compete in the Babe Ruth World Series, the Force earned the Dalton CRA Softball Tournament title with a 10-0 win over the Saratoga Thunder, at Pine Grove Park.
Amanda Pou threw a no-hitter and every batter in the lineup reached base to contribute in the victory. Only one Thunder player reached base, and she was quickly thrown out by catcher Issabelle Macdonald and she attempted to steal second.
“We played Chatham yesterday and we didn’t play well, but we came out today and we were a totally different team and we were ready to play,” Coach Glebus said. “Our bats were alive, our defense was alive and our pitching was outstanding. I’m not complaining, but for some reason, on Sundays we come out alive. We really did play well today, and that’s when it counts.”
The Force won their Babe Ruth New England Regional earlier this summer to qualify for the World Series. The team heads down to Jensen Beach, Florida, on Thursday, and this tournament served as a nice dress rehearsal for the action ahead.
By 2010, the old YMCA boathouse was just about to fall into the lake because it had fallen into such disrepair.
Scott Graves then had an idea to save it. He'd take the property that wasn't one the tax rolls, renovate it and turn it into a private marina and club. Instead of the city ultimately... click for more
More than two dozen teenagers from Camp Lenox spent Friday cleaning up the west side of Pittsfield.
In partnership with Central Berkshire Habitat for Humanity, the campers cleaned up Durant Park, Columbus Avenue, and opened up the staircase at the end of Francis Avenue that had become overgrown... click for more
When Patrick Kavey returned to his hometown he had trouble finding work.
"I started applying to professional jobs. I had an interesting time finding either a job that would compensate me based on what you would see for an area of this size in the region or just finding specific jobs in general,"... click for more
Wetland issues have derailed planned improvements to Pontsoosuc Lake Park.
The Friends of Pontoosuc Lake received $15,000 from the Community Preservation Act with the intent to restore the beach on the Hancock Road side. The city's Parks, Open Space and Natural Resource Program Manager Jim... click for more
When two men came whipping into the city with police on their tail in March, residents didn't see Pittsfield Police officers hanging out the window shooting their guns off trying to blow out the tires. That only happens in movies.
In fact, residents didn't see Pittsfield Police on the suspect's... click for more