WILLIAMSTOWN, Mass. — The Mount Greylock Regional School District is still waiting for proposal from its architect to design new athletic fields, more than a month after the School Committee authorized the administration to move forward on obtaining those designs.
But while the committee was not able to take any action on the project at its Thursday meeting, it did hear from critics of the plan to install a synthetic turf multisport field at the middle/high school.
District Business Administrator Joe Bergeron on Thursday reported that architect Perkins Eastman did not provide a proposal for its design services in time for the School Committee to consider awarding the contract on Thursday night.
"Which is a little frustrating because it's been weeks in the making," Bergeron told the panel. "That is all the update I have right now.
"We're trying as hard as we can within the district to move the process forward."
In the past, Bergeron has told the committee that it would be optimal to get the project out to bid this fall in order to hit contractors' cycles at an optimal time and, in theory, install the new field in 2022.
But the district needs new bid documents, and the School Committee in September tasked the administration with getting an agreement from Boston architect Perkins Eastman to draw up those documents.
The School Committee has long planned to pay for a new field with proceeds from a $5 million capital gift the middle/high school received from Williams College in 2016, at the outset of a building project at Mount Greylock.
This week, the School Committee learned that the value of that gift, as of June 2021, was $4.7 million.
That takes into account $2.1 million in growth in fiscal 2021 and $3.1 million spent or committed to be spent since July 1, 2020.
The cost of a "fields project" that included the turf field and needed improvements to the existing field twice came in over a number that the School Committee felt comfortable paying. That led the committee earlier this year to break the Title IX and Americans with Disabilities Act improvements apart from the turf field; the ADA and Title IX work currently is underway and on target to be completed by an April 2022 deadline from the commonwealth's Architectural Access Board.
The artificial turf field, meanwhile, continues to draw criticism from some members of the community.
Three long-standing critics, Anne O'Connor, Susan Abrams and Stephanie Boyd, addressed the School Committee at the start of Thursday's meeting to express their dismay over the September vote.
"Children in the world are dying from the effects of the climate crisis, and you're telling our children what they need is a big plastic field," said O'Connor, who told the committee she was "mad" over the move to advance the synthetic turf field forward.
Abrams pointed to recent research supporting the notion that artificial fields can contribute to orthopedic injuries and concussions
She also said that, as the parent of former athletes at the middle/high school, she never saw evidence that the inadequacy of the school's natural grass fields prevented kids from being involved in sports.
And, like O'Connor, she attempted to put the School Committee's September vote into an environmental context.
"I want to remind the committee that this community, Williamstown, made a commitment [at 2021's annual town meeting] to net zero carbon emissions by 2050, which means we have to take that into consideration in all our projects going forward," Abrams said.
"Artificial turf fields do make a significant contribution to greenhouse gas emissions. A grass field sequesters carbon — even with the mowing and other care, there is a net reduction in carbon emissions."
Boyd emphasized the argument that artificial turf fields are not recyclable and not likely to be recyclable given how much cheaper it is to produce new synthetic field materials. And, along with Abrams, Boyd talked about the presence of polyfluoroalkyl, or PFAS, substances in the materials used in artificial turf fields.
"Even if it doesn't contaminate the site at Mount Greylock, which it might do, there is pollution at the site where it's manufactured, and we'd be contributing to that," Boyd said. "There's no way we can ask for a field that doesn't include PFAS. It's how they're manufactured."
No School Committee members addressed the comments against the turf field or discussed the synthetic turf field project at all once Bergeron informed the panel that there was no proposal to consider from the architect.
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.
Your Comments
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
No Comments
Hancock Town Meeting Votes to Strike Meme Some Found 'Divisive'
By Stephen DravisiBerkshires Staff
Hancock town meeting members Monday vote on a routine item early in the meeting.
HANCOCK, Mass. — By the narrowest of margins Monday, the annual town meeting voted to strike from the town report messaging that some residents described as, "inflammatory," "divisive" and unwelcoming to new residents.
On a vote of 50-48, the meeting voted to remove the inside cover of the report as it appeared on the town website and in printed versions distributed prior to the meeting and at the elementary school on Monday night.
The text, which appeared to be a reprinted version of an Internet meme, read, "You came here from there because you didn't like it there, and now you want to change here to be like there. You are welcome here, only don't try to make here like there. If you want to make here like there, you shouldn't have left there in the first place."
After the meeting breezed through the first 18 articles on the town meeting warrant agenda with hardly a dissenting vote, a member rose to ask if it would be unreasonable for the meeting to vote to remove the meme under Article 19, the "other business" article.
"No, you cannot remove it," Board of Selectmen Chair Sherman Derby answered immediately.
After it became clear that Moderator Brian Fairbank would entertain discussion about the meme, Derby took the floor to address the issue that has been discussed in town circles since the report was printed earlier this spring.
"Let me tell you about something that happened this year," Derby said. "The School Department got rid of Christmas. And they got rid of Columbus Day. Now it's Indigenous People's Day.
Town meeting voters will be asked Monday to approve a request to change state law in a way that will preserve education at Hancock Elementary School. click for more
The Charter Review Committee on Wednesday voted unanimously to endorse an amended version of the compliance provision it drafted to be added to the Town Charter. click for more
Developer David Traggorth asked the trustees to make the contribution from its coffers to help unlock an additional $5.4 million in state funds for the planned 54-unit apartment building at the south end of the Cable Mills site.
click for more