North Adams School Officials Back Coalition Protesting Mandates, Testing

By Tammy DanielsiBerkshires Staff
Print Story | Email Story
The School Committee voted to endorse a coalition asking the state to provide relief from unfunded mandates and excessive regulation.

NORTH ADAMS, Mass. — The School Committee unanimously endorsed the mission goals of a recently created educational coalition formed to voice concerns on unfunded mandates and excessive testing.

The Western Massachusetts Educational Leaders Coalition, primarily made up of a schools in the Pioneer Valley, formed last summer. Comprised of nine superintendents, a dozen school committee members representing 10 districts and the executive directors of two educational collaboratives, the coalition is hoping to impress upon the state the obstacles and challenges being forced on local school districts to the detriment of their students' education.

The coalition's frustration is with "the amount, unrealistic pace and unmanagable cost of a variety of required state and federal initiatives," according to its statement.

School Committee John Hockridge, who presented the mission statement, said the coalition was being supported by the Massachusetts Association of School Committees and is reaching out to other school districts to "provide as large and unified a voice as possible."

Among the more recent issues being brought to bear on local districts is the implementation of the new Common Core standards, the new framework for teacher evaluations, new "District Determined Measures" assessments and new standardized testing through the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers.

"All these mandates that have come down over the years have come from outside of us ... it's not coming from the school committee, not coming from the teachers, not coming from school administration," Hockridge said. "It's coming from DESE and others — legislators and those outside the school environment.

"I just kind of feel we've sat back and taken it all over the years and done the best we can. ...  What this is saying is it's become too much for a lot of us and for the school system in general."

Fellow committee members agreed, with Lawrence Taft saying one of the most common concerns of teachers in contract negotiations is the time spent on preparing standardized testing and assessments.

"They're doing too much testing, there's too many initiatives, they can't keep up with the initiatives," he said, adding he "personally endorsed" the statement.

Based on testimony from MASC Executive Director Tom Scott in the statement, the Department of Elementary and Secondary Educuation between 1996 and 2008 had promulgated 4,055 documents requiring school district action. Between 2009 and 2013, that number increased dramatically to 5,382, or an average of 1,077 multipage documents a year.

Children are subjected to 23 different standardized tests; between Grades 3 and 10, the average child will sit for 39 test sessions. About 10 days per school year are spent administering and scheduling tests; Drury High Principal Amy Meehan thought it closer to 25 at the high school level.


Superintendent James Montepare estimated that some 70 days out of the 180-day school year are tied up with MCAS testing, assessments or teacher evaluations.  

There's also the cost: About $35 million a year is spent on Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System testing, according to the Brookings Institute. Administrators are also concerned about the possible implementation of the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers testing that will be done online - with school districts picking up the tab for new technology.

Hockridge said there is a lot of concern on both the left and right political spectrum about Common Core and mandates. It's not a political stance, he said, but concern over issues that directly impact students, teachers and taxpayers.

"Give us a break. ... Let's find a way to create a quality learning environment without these obstacles you keep putting in our way," he said.

The committee voted to endorse the statement to give Hockridge support as he reaches out to other school districts in the Berkshires.

In other business, the committee discussed the latest "Condition of Education in the Commonwealth" published by the Rennie Center for Education Research and Policy.

Montepare said the school district had been working on the reports goals for some time.

"It's very simple: all supports will end up in the classroom providing primary program for all students; keep kids actively engaged and on track for graduation and college," he said. "This is not a new concept."

Some of these ideals were first implemented at Johnson School in 1993 and then Brayton a year later, ecompassing the school district to ensure all instruction if all possible is done in the classroom. The school system also provides a wide array of extracurricular activities and supports.

Taft said he read the report expecting to see North Adams cited at the end because many of the recommendations were already in place.

Vice Chairwoman Heather Boulger said a representative from DESE had been "blown away" by a visit to Drury's College and Career Readiness Center. Committee members agreed they needed to market the school system's best elements, such as community service learning, career readiness and its expansive arts program.

WMELC Statement


Tags: MCAS,   North Adams School Committee,   PARCC,   unfunded mandates,   

If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.

McCann Making Progress Toward MCAS Targets

By Jack GuerinoiBerkshires Staff

NORTH ADAMS, Mass. — McCann Tech Principal Justin Kratz told the Northern Berkshire Vocational Regional School District School Committee last week that because the school is making substantial progress toward its 2026 MCAS targets, there will be no Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE) intervention.

"So long story short, we are not on DESE's radar for MCAS performance," he said. "At the end of the day, that is what is what we are after."

Kratz said McCann scored "a ton" of points, showing growth in most categories. He said they earned 75 percent of total possible points for all students and 83 percent of all possible points for lowest-performing students.

Kratz noted that DESE tends to change targets and formulas every year. But he drew attention to the year 2025, when a passing MCAS score was no longer a graduation requirement. In 2025, McCann received 33 percent of the possible points and 7 percent for the lowest-performing students. This equaled a score of 20 percent.

"That was the year where everything went off the cliff," he said. "We didn't do very well. This year was 79 percent, and that is knocking it out of the park. ... If we followed up with another 20, we would have been in rough water."

Kratz added this drop was typical across the state, saying he assumed students just took the test less seriously. He wanted to demonstrate how the scores and targets are "reshuffled" and gave a closer look at English scores over the years.

In 2024, the school had a target of 499.3 (average scaled score). The school scored 500.4. In 2025, McCann's new target was 502.5, but McCann scored 485.6. McCann's 2026 target was 487.7, and they scored 486.8.

Kratz said McCann is not scoring as high as they were in 2024, but they are getting more points. He said sometimes the scores needed to be taken with a "grain of salt."

He underlined that although MCAS is important in a vocational education, it only represents half of what a student does in a given school year. 

"There is no MCAS for 50 percent of their time here, which is their trade area," Kratz said. "They [DESE] don't assess that ... so this one little pocket is important, but it doesn't show the entire picture of a student."

Kratz moved from what he called the "good" section of his presentation to the "awesome." He said McCann was recognized as one of 55 schools that drastically improved chronic absenteeism by at least 5 percentage points. He said the school received a letter from DESE congratulating them that included a survey that asked how the school did it.

"It was a nice letter, but we kind of laughed and asked, 'What did we do?' " he said. "I say that sort of tongue-in-cheek because we didn't do any sort of targeted attendance improvement initiative."

He said the more he thought about it, the more he attributed the change to standardized grading and improving the school environment physically and culturally.  

"We didn't do all that wanting to improve attendance. We did it because we wanted to create more equity, and ... I think that is a byproduct of that," Kratz said. "Kids are more likely to want to go to school if that 62 they got on a test does not bury them for the rest of the year. They know they can dig their way out of it. And they are more likely to go to school if the building is a little brighter when they walk in in the morning."

Also, the importance of attendance is baked into the vocational school experience.

View Full Story

More North Adams Stories