LEE, Mass. — Local school officials pressed members of the Berkshire delegation to make education funding a priority in the coming legislative year.
And the legislators urged them to keep up the pressure.
"The pressure we feel at home can translate into action at the State House," said state Rep. Tricia Farley-Bouvier, explaining that when they speak with legislative leaders, "I can go and say this is the most important issue in Pittsfield."
But while the Pittsfield representative is a firm believer in grassroots activism, she said the critical part of the equation is finding new revenue.
"We're underfunding Chapter 70 [education aid] by $2 billion a year ... we're all fighting over crumbs," Farley-Bouvier told the annual meeting of the Massachusetts Association of School Committees Division VI in the Lee High School cafeteria on Monday. "The real solution is to get more revenue. The millionaire's tax is a good way to do it."
With the so-called "millionaire's tax" off the ballot in November, an anticipated $1.5 billion in revenue is also off the table.
"A lot of this was dependent on the millionaire's tax," said state Rep. William "Smitty" Pignatelli. "That took a billion and a half to $2 billion we thought we were going to have."
The amendment would have instituted a 4 percent tax on any income after the first $1 million. It would not have been applied to assets. The amendment had made it through two consecutive constitutional convention votes and was set to go before the voters but was struck down by the Supreme Judicial Court less than two weeks before the end of the fiscal year.
Frustrated lawmakers had pegged the added revenue to education and transportation, but the court had blocked the ballot question precisely because it related taxing and spending in a single question.
The House and Senate then attempted to craft a compromise education bill that would offer additional resources for special education and employee health benefits in the school funding formula during the final days of the session but that, too, failed.
Pignatelli, in response to questions from school officials, said the education funding talks had largely collapsed because there wasn't anyone to talk to on the Senate side.
"The differences were very dramatic," he said of the bills on each side. "We were scheduled to be there the entire weekend ... The Senate changed leadership on Thursday and they went home for the weekend. We went home because there was nobody to talk to ... for the last five days we didn't have any dance partners."
Senators blamed the House leadership for failing to make any traction on the recommendations made by the last Foundation Budget Review Commission in 2015.
"I feel slightly more optimistic next year we'll see changes," said state Sen. Adam Hinds. "This and some other changes have to be at the top of the list."
Pignatelli agreed that there will be a lot to take up in the next session: "I would hate to see another fiscal year budget get approved without solving some of these problems."
Farley-Bouvier was still hopeful that millionaire's tax could be resurrected in a way that satisfied the Supreme Judicial Court, but that solution will now be several years away.
"We have a way to collect revenue for the 20th century but we need a way to collect revenue for the 21st century," she said.
Pignatelli noted that there'd already been several panaceas floated over the years to supplement the state's coffers — like casinos and marijuana — that are just now getting started.
"There's a different momentum going into this legislative session that we have to do this," he said. "The burden on the local municipalities and the local taxpayers is growing and we have to step up."
But he added, lawmakers know the problem and perhaps the people working and overseeing the schools can provide some solutions.
"The rate of inflation hasn't kept pace with the growth of state revenue ... when you cut a teacher, you cut a program. People ask why are you doing this because they don't know how the system works," said Glenn Koocher, MASC executive director. School officials get "kicked in the shin" so they turn to state officials in their frustration. "We go to the Legislature and 'say fix this.'"
But Koocher also noted that MASC had asked lawmakers to go a little slower in ensuring that real fixes were made to the foundation budget, particularly the accounting for children who are economically disadvantaged but don't show up through traditional means of access to social services.
A school's foundation budget is calculated by factors including the number of children, the cost of administrative services, special education and economic disadvantage to determine the cost to adequately educate a student. Using Lee and Lenox as examples, Koocher explained how Lee's cost per pupil is higher because it has more students requiring services.
"The more economically disadvantaged, the higher your budget," he said. "The theory is you wouldn't need as much money to educate students who were not at economic risk."
School officials are advocating for foundation budgets to better reflect costs that are eating up budgets like health insurance, retiree benefits and special education. MASC is also asking for better accounting of children at economic risk, specifically undocumented children, who cannot receive the benefits that are used to quantify low-income students.
"There are no right answers and there are no easy answers," Koocher said. "The reason we are still working on getting the foundation budget done is we have so many unanswered questions. ...
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue; please keep comments focused on the issues and not on personalities. Profanity, obscenity, racist language and harassment are not allowed. iBerkshires reserves the right to ban commenters or remove commenting on any article at any time. Concerns may be sent to firstname.lastname@example.org.
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
Gotta Dance, Gotta Sing: There's Both This Week on Local Stages
By Grace LichtensteinGuest Column
Downtown Pittsfield Third Thursdays — TL Collective
Each third Thursday of the month, streets are closed in downtown Pittsfield and all kinds of music rocks the city. Featured June 20 at 6 p.m. in the Dance Zone at the north end of the street festival is TL Collective, the athletic, family-friendly contemporary and hip-hop moves of Micaela Taylor's company. The group performs an evening length work "Drift." The aim, according to organizers, is to "demonstrate an individual's ever-changing relationship to self while exposing a personal season of self-growth."
You can find the dance zone near the corner of Bradford and North Streets in front of St. Joseph’s Church. This program is a presentation of the Berkshires stalwart Jacob's Pillow.
Ballet BC is coming to Jacob's Pillow this week.
At the Pillow's expansive home in Becket, the featured company in the Ted Shawn Theater this week is Ballet BC, which is celebrating 10 years under the innovative leadership of artistic director and former company member Emily Molnar.
"Truly contemporary" is how one reviewer described the Vancouver-based troupe. On the bill this week is Molnar's most recent work "To this day," along with the U.S. premiere of "Bedroom Folk." The latter work originated with the Nederlands Dans Theater and was created by Israeli collaborators Sharon Eyal and Gai Behar, among others.
This program runs Wednesday, June 19, through Sunday, June 23, at 8 p.m., with matinees on Saturday and Sunday in addition to evenings.
Nancy Gomez arrived in American in the fall of 2017 with a dream for her family to own their own home.
She came from Columbia with her husband, three children, and pregnant. In a new country, the financial system was intimidating. But she had gained some confidence through places like the Family... click for more
The design efforts to restore the Springside Pond is entering the permitting phase.
Parks and Open Spaces Manager Jim McGrath updated the Parks Commission on Tuesday about the progress and said the city will be seeking permits from the Conservation Commission in the coming weeks. However, the... click for more
Two newly hired firefighters resigned after it was found they had falsely claimed residency to get a boost in the Civil Service exam.
The Civil Service Commission called for an investigation into the matter after a bypass appeal was filed late last fall. Justin Brady had taken the exam but did... click for more
The state hopes to see more renewable energy from solar and thus incentives solar development. However, the way the programs are currently established, the solar often comes at the expense of cutting trees.
"We have perverse incentives for solar. It is cheaper for a developer to come in and cut... click for more
Thanks to a $900,000 state grant, Herberg Middle School is poised to vastly improve the academics in the building.
Herberg has had low scores on state assessments leading it into "turnaround status" and Principal Martin McEvoy and Assistant Principal for Teaching and Learning Lisa Lesser crafted... click for more
Christian Womble tossed a complete-game with 10 strikeouts and scored the first run, and Anton Lazits had a solo home run to lead Taconic to a 5-1 win over Wahconah in the Western Mass Division 3 championship at UMass on Saturday. click for more