A crowd was on hand to hear the final vote on which elementary school would close.
CHESHIRE, Mass. — The Adams-Cheshire Regional School Committee voted 4-3 to close Cheshire Elementary School on Thursday night, splitting along town lines.
The anticipated vote came after a nearly two hour meeting at Hoosac Valley High School and was one of five taken to reconfigure the regional school district, including moving Grades 4 and 5 up to Hoosac Valley.
"This is short-term solution and we have to think about the future …I wish we did not have to make this decision but our budget demands us to do something," Superintendent of Schools Robert Putnam said. "What we do tonight is not necessarily what the future is."
Of the two votes taken on which school keep open, three Cheshire representatives — Darlene Rodowicz, Peter Tatro and Edmund St. John IV — voted to keep Cheshire Elementary School open and the four Adams representatives — Stephan Vigna, Regina Hill, Jennifer Gageant and Paul Butler — voted to keep C.T. Plunkett School open.
Before voting the School Committee members made final statements.
Vigna said his decision was based on all the data and input from the public but he also put himself in the shoes of the students and felt the more recently renovated Plunkett offered a better educational opportunity.
"Some would say improving education is only made attributable through more dollars, and this may be true but I always agreed that the environment in which a student learns plays just as an important role in their overall education," Vigna said.
Hill said that although she saw great things in both schools, she felt Plunkett offered more space, more opportunity and would allow for more enrollment in the future.
"I believe that the only sound decision educationally and more responsible decision fiscally that I can support is to close Cheshire and consolidate into C.T. Plunkett," Hill said.
On the Cheshire side, St. John said closing Cheshire would only take additional transportation reimbursement funds and other savings out of the classroom.
"We hear the needs of our teachers and staff and they need support and we need to be able to ensure funding not only for this year but for the years to come," he said. "My fear is closing Cheshire does not put any resources back into the classroom … I feel like it is educationally irresponsible to take those funds away from our children."
Rodowicz said both schools can handle the number of children and will house the same teachers so the education will not change. What will change is increased funding that can help improve education if Cheshire were to stay open.
Residents filled a majority of the Hoosac Valley auditorium and those who spoke reiterated arguments for each building made in the many past public meetings to gather input from the residents. However, some residents asked that both communities look forward.
"This feels a little bit like a Band Aid and there is a long term we have to look at. We close a school either one is a long-term solution," Cheshire resident John Tremblay said. "I challenge the leaders of both towns to come together along with the people and not have it be Adams against Cheshire."
Putnam said he would like to create a committee with members of both towns to create a vision for the future of the district that both communities can get behind. With a substantial renovation or new build over five years away, he said there is time to create this vision.
The School Committee will vote on the fiscal 2018 budget Monday. The budget scenarios range from cutting staff and only hiring a few of the recently recommended positions to stay within a 3 percent increase for Adams to a budget that will have all five recommended positions but that will require a Proposition 2 1/2 override.
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.
Your Comments
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
No Comments
School Budget Has Cheshire Pondering Prop 2.5 Override
By Daniel MatziBerkshires correspondent
CHESHIRE, Mass. — The Board of Selectmen voted to schedule a Proposition 2.5 override vote, a move seen as a precaution to cover funding for the Hoosac Valley Regional School District if an agreement between the school and town cannot be reached.
The town's 2025 fiscal year budget is still being finalized, and while budget totals were not available as of Tuesday night, town leaders have already expressed concerns regarding the HVRSD's proposed $23 million budget, which would include a $3,097,123 assessment for Cheshire, reflecting a $148,661 increase.
The board did share that its early budget drafts maintain most town spending at current levels and defer several projects and purchases. Chairman Shawn McGrath said with a level-funded HVRSD budget, Cheshire would face a $165,838 budget gap. He believed this was an amount the town could safely pull from free cash and reserves.
However, with Hoosac's proposed budget increase, this budget gap is closer to $316,000, an amount member Jason Levesque did not want to drain from the town reserves.
"I am not comfortable blowing through all of the stuff we have nitpicked over the last couple of years to save up for just to meet their budget," he said. "I am not OK with that. We have way too many other things that have been kicked down the road forever and every year they always get their check cashed."
The Selectmen agreed the only way to meet this increase would be for the town to pass an override that would permit it to increase property taxes beyond the state's 2.5 percent cap, an action requiring approval from Cheshire residents in a townwide vote as well as town meeting approval.
Selectwoman Michelle Francesconi said that without an override, the town would have to cut even deeper into the municipal budget, further derailing town projects and needs.
Desroches graduated from the Police Academy on March 22 in the top tier in his class. He's currently in the field training program and assigned to Sgt. Curtis Crane.
click for more
Michael Wynn, who was selected in January to run the center, submitted a level operating budget of $57,500 but said he could pull funding from different lines to ensure there was money for advertising this fall.
click for more
The Selectmen on Wednesday night voted to award the bid to Mackin Construction Co. Inc. of Greenfield, which plans to invest $11 million to build out 20 or more one- and two-bedroom apartments in the three-story classroom wing that parallels Columbia Street.
click for more
The Selectmen two weeks ago had requested the utility appear before the board after receiving numerous complaints over flickering lights, including in Town Hall.
click for more
Taylor Garabedian scored a team-high 22 points and grabbed five rebounds, and Abby Scialabba scored 16 points for the ‘Canes, who got 16 points, nine rebounds and four assists from Ashlyn Lesure. click for more