
Pittsfield School Committee Member, Teacher's Union Settle Complaint Without Censure
![]() |
| Batory defended her actions as in compliance, and asserted that it is her job to help families bring concerns to district leadership. |
PITTSFIELD, Mass.— A School Committee member and the teachers' union came to some agreement in public session last week after a complaint was filed against the elected official.
On the table was a motion to censure School Committee member Ciara Batory on the allegation that she inserted herself into an administrative personnel matter and acted outside of policy.
This and four other restorative motions were proposed by the United Educators of Pittsfield months after concerns were brought forward about an educator collecting students' personal contact information on social media.
The committee took no action on the censure, which is to issue a formal, public statement of strong disapproval or harsh criticism against someone, and accepted that the rest of the allegations had been addressed in an hour and a half of deliberation.
"I know it took everybody's time, but we, as a body, are concerned that this is going to continue like this, and we do have a lot of serious issues in this district that need to be addressed, like really serious things. The children in this city need help," UEP President James Hurley said.
"They do," Batory replied. "And I think that we should work on that."
Batory defended her actions as in compliance, and asserted that it is her job to help families bring concerns to district leadership. She also apologized for any resulting collateral damage in staff morale, and committed to a meeting with the union for further discussion.
"I'm so sorry because I do feel like this obviously was taken out on the teacher, and it shouldn't have been," she said.
"It should have been taken out on the administration because they didn't do their job, and if they did, I think that a statement could have went out, and parents wouldn't have been so upset."
Chair Peter Marchetti called for a short recess before the complaint was taken out of order on the agenda so that other members of the School Committee could read it. Batory chose to have the conversation in open session.
Hurley said the union is concerned that Batory has "repeatedly inserted herself as an individual school committee member into complaints and personnel matters involving teachers, publicly discussed those matters on social media, and encouraged members of the public to copy her directly on complaints concerning school employees."
This, he said, became particularly egregious during a recent personnel matter involving a UEP bargaining unit member.
"While the district was addressing the matter through its established procedures, [Batory] repeatedly posted publicly about the personnel matter from a Facebook page, where she identifies herself as a School Committee member. Among other things, she publicly questioned what corrective or disciplinary action had been taken, discussed whether the employees should be held accountable, stated that she could contact school administrators regarding the matter, and encouraged people with accusations or concerns involving teachers to contact the superintendent and copy her directly," he said.
The UEP alleged this conduct is inconsistent with the responsibilities and standards expected of School Committee members to "respect the administrative chain of command, refer complaints to the proper school authorities, avoid independently acting in personnel matters, and recognize that authority rests with the school committee as a body rather than with individual members."
The union said this amplified and prolonged the situation, and turned an individual personnel matter into a much larger public conflict.
"Regardless of the merits of the underlying personnel matter, this kind of public involvement by an individual School Committee member creates an unnecessary escalation, undermines confidence in established procedures and causes bargaining unit members to question whether their own complaints, personnel matters, or disciplinary issues will be handled fairly and professionally," Hurley said.
The union said elected school officials should help direct concerns to the appropriate channel and help maintain confidence in the district's processes instead of contributing to "unnecessary escalation involving individual employees."
The UEP asked that the School Committee:
- Formally review Batory's overall conduct in connection with this matter, including her social media activity, involvement in complaints concerning school employees, communications with administrators, and her use of position as a school committee member.
- Formally censure Batory for conduct that the committee determines to be inconsistent with the responsibilities, standards, and policies applicable to School Committee members.
- Take meaningful corrective action that reflects the seriousness and overall pattern of Batory's conduct.
- Take appropriate steps to ensure that individual School Committee members do not personally insert themselves into employee complaints or personnel matters outside established procedures.
- Take any other actions with the committee's authority necessary to address the harm caused and prevent similar conduct from continuing.
If the committee fails to take meaningful action, the UEP reserves the right to pursue all additional contractual, administrative, statutory, and legal remedies available.
Batory said her words preserved on social media (Facebook) completely disprove this accusation. She added that she did not name an employee or school location, but addressed a matter of critical public concern: students' boundaries and data privacy.
"A censure is a tool meant for gross misconduct or a violation of law. Using it to silence an elected official for engaging in a public discourse about student safety sets a dangerous precedent," the school committee member said to her colleagues.
"It signals to every parent in Pittsfield that their elected representative cares more about protecting institutional systems from scrutiny than protecting their children. I did not violate policy. I upheld my oath of office."
She reported explicitly telling constituents to contact the superintendent, and said asking to be copied on those communications is not administrative interference, but constituent accountability.
Batory asked that Heather McNeice, Sarah Muil, and Katherine Yon recuse themselves for having current or past professional ties to unionized educators.
They did not recuse themselves. The Pittsfield Public Schools' attorney, Russell Dupere, saw no conflict of interest and pointed out, for example, that the committee votes on teacher contract litigation involving unions.
Muil said she has never been part of a union and is a teacher under the Department of Early and Secondary Education; McNeice said she is not a member of the UEP and doesn't think being a teacher is a conflict of interest; and Yon disclosed that she was a teacher for nearly 40 years, belonging to the American Federation of Teachers and the UEP.
"The idea is not that I want to silence you, but when you're speaking that way, I feel like a lot of people are silenced because they're just put on the defense of what's coming next," McNeice said.
"So we need to work on tone."
Batory was commended for her ideas and passion about the school system.
"To be honest with you, the things you say are really interesting. I think you have a point of view on this committee that no one else has. But I think it gets to a point," Hurley said.
"…That person that it happened to, his life has turned upside down because of it. And now we're all sitting back saying it's going to happen to us next."
Marchetti said the exchange between Batory and Hurley addressed most of the action items listed in the complaint. He preferred not to take a vote to censure her at this time.
During the meeting, the committee went through screenshots of the posts in question and the chain of command when a concern is brought forward. A few community members, including her fiancé, spoke in support of her during public comment.
"I feel, in my heart of hearts, in all honesty, and with no skin in the game, that Ciara Batory is being made the scapegoat by the UEP," resident Beth Robinson said.
"A parent of a student who was having an issue reached out to her. She is a School Committee member. I don't know why everybody reaches out to Ciara. Maybe you should all ask yourselves why they don't reach out to other members as well."
The administration did not respond to Batory's testimony of not getting responses from the superintendent's office and being the last resort for parents who have exhausted the other channels.
Later in the nearly four-hour meeting, McNeice clarified she was uncomfortable with a comment made earlier about administration being the problem.
"I don't think that administration is the problem. I don't think teachers are the problem. I don't think kids are the problem, and I don't think parents are the problem. I think the problem is we don't have enough adults and enough expertise to deal with the problems," she said.
"And so when we look at the budget moving forward. I know we're going to have to say, 'This is how much money we have, and this is what we can do,' But I think we also need to look at how much money do we need to actually solve these problems, because it's no one person's fault. We just don't have the resources that it takes to help the children that so desperately need our help, and to support the teachers and staff."
Tags: Pittsfield Public Schools,

