Town meeting members, socially distanced in the bleachers at Williams College's Weston Field athletic complex, make a non-controversial vote early in Tuesday's meeting.
WILLIAMSTOWN, Mass. — After voting against the idea of delaying action on a pair of competing marijuana zoning bylaws and sending them back to the Planning Board, town meeting Tuesday voted down both proposals … and put the issue back in the lap of the Planning Board after all.
Williamstown's first recorded outdoor town meeting, held at Williams College's Weston Field athletic complex, started with the members facing conflicting bylaw amendments: one, proposed by the Planning Board, which would have placed tougher restrictions on indoor production of cannabis and eliminated outdoor cultivation in all the town's zoning districts and a second, drafted by the town's Agricultural Commission, which looked to continue to allow outdoor cultivation though with stricter controls than the 2017 bylaw enacted by town meeting.
To make matters a little more confusing, a bare majority of the Planning Board recommended passage of the Ag Commission's draft, which was placed on the town meeting warrant via citizen's petition.
And if that was not clear enough, both the Planning Board and the lone member of the Ag Commission to address the meeting recommended postponing any action on either amendment so that the two articles potentially could be reconciled for presentation at the 2021 annual town meeting.
That was the first vote on the issue, held after about 50 minutes of debate that focused less on the idea of postponement and more on the merits of the competing articles; Town Moderator Adam Filson encouraged debate on the amendments themselves before the meeting acted on the idea of referring the measures back to committee.
That delaying action failed on a vote of 162-130.
That then set the stage for decisions on both the Planning Board article, No. 33 on the warrant, and the Ag Commission article, No. 34.
Both articles ended up being amended before they went to a vote.
The former, which previously would have disallowed outdoor cultivation throughout the town, was amended to insert language allowing outdoor cultivation by special permit in two zoning districts — Rural Residence 2 and Rural Residence 3 — under a "microbusiness" model that allows only up to 5,000 square feet of growing area
The latter, which, as drafted would have allowed up to 50,000 square feet of growing "canopy," was similarly amended with the 5,000-square-foot limitation.
As with all zoning bylaws, either Article 33 or 34 — or both — would have needed a two-thirds majority for passage.
Instead, each was favored by a majority of town residents but not the needed two-thirds supermajority.
Article 33, the Planning Board's draft, received 156 yeas and 106 nays; it needed 175 affirmative votes for passage.
Article 34, the Ag Commission's version, garnered 122 yeas and 104 nays; it needed 151 yes votes.
That means that the Planning Board likely will have the issue on its plate for another year — albeit an abbreviated year if next year's annual town meeting is held in May, as is custom, and not delayed again by the COVID-19 pandemic.
It was not the only setback for the Planning Board, which saw one of its other proposed bylaw amendments postponed. The board had proposed an amendment that created new rules for long and common driveways, but each proposal drew negative comments from the floor of the meeting and concerns that neither had received sufficient public comment in a year when the board's deliberations were dominated by discussions about the marijuana bylaw amendments.
On a "voice vote," Filson determined that a motion to delay the article passed. Actually, there were no true voice votes at the meeting. All votes were cast by holding either a red "no" or green "yes" voting card, but Filson determined there was a clear enough majority to postpone the article without ordering a formal count.
In fact, most of the articles at the nearly four-hour meeting passed by wide margins, and, as usual, much of the warrant was approved without comment.
But only a few measures appeared to be truly unanimous, and two of those came at the meeting's end, when the town approved the "Not In Our County" pledge and OK'd a second warrant article, titled "Equity," that requires the town to provide equity training to its employees and that all town boards and committees "reexamine and continue to create their policies and practices according to a commitment to accessible living."
Both articles appeared on the warrant by way of citizen's petition. They came after the killing of George Flloyd in May but before last week's revelation of allegations of discrimination and sexual assault in the Williamstown Police Department.
"This citizen's petition is an effort to support the work of the new Diversity, Inclusion, Race and Equity Committee set up by the Select Board,” Arlene Kirsch said in support of the Not In Our County warrant article. “In the wake of all the recent news, I'd think we'd all want to do that."
Speaking in favor of the Equity article, Huff Templeton explained that it could help the town move forward on issues of inclusion.
"This motion is about equity, but it's also about accountability and growth through training," Templeton said. "This is a motion that says: We want our government to act in a proactive way to invite different types of people, traditionally marginalized groups into our neighborhoods, into our communities. We will address systemic racism through education, and we expect all agents of the town to work toward this goal."
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.
Your Comments
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
No Comments
Neal Touts Federal Aid to Support Renovation of Symbol of Democracy
By Stephen DravisiBerkshires Staff
Congressman Richard Neal looks at historic photos of the 19th-century meetinghouse during a tour Thursday.
WILLIAMSTOWN, Mass. — A longtime Democratic member of Congress on Thursday lauded the democratic ideals embodied in a local landmark.
U.S. Rep. Richard Neal, D-Springfield, was in town to celebrate a $500,000 federal earmark to support the renovation of the Williamstown Meetinghouse, a project that will make the iconic structure more compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act and more accessible to members of the community.
Referencing the 1869 structure's connection to the town's 1765 founding (the first two meetinghouses burned down), Neal drew a line from Thursday's celebration to a much better known party happening at the other end of the commonwealth this week.
"I hope I'm going to be there on Saturday morning, that's my plan, to be in Concord and Lexington for the acknowledgement of what happened 250 years ago, because that's what we honor with the Meetinghouse: Representative democracy, where people have the right to assemble and petition their government and to make their voices heard," Neal said in prepared remarks on the meetinghouse steps.
"That's what the meetinghouse meant. It was very much in the Puritan history. After a church was constructed, a Congregational church, generally, nearby, there was the library and the meetinghouse. It's all over New England in these beautiful little towns that I represent."
Since 2013, Williamstown has been on that list of towns represented by Neal, a former Springfield mayor who has served in the House of Representatives since 1986. After the 2010 Census, Neal became Williamstown's representative from the newly drawn 1st Congressional District.
On Thursday, he was joined on the meetinghouse steps by state Rep. John Barrett III, D-North Adams, Sherwood Guernsey of the Berkshire Democratic Brigades and Carolyn Greene, president of the Williamstown Meetinghouse Preservation Fund.
Neal, an 18-term member of Congress and ranking member of the House Judiciary Committee, said the best course of action for his party on Capitol Hill is to splinter the GOP's 220-213 majority.
click for more
About 20 residents and the majority of the Select Board on Monday sent a message to the Hoosac Water Quality District: importing sludge and converting it to compost is a bad deal and unethical.
click for more
Karen DuCharme has been a teacher for 24 years, starting at Pittsfield High School, and has been at Mount Greylock Regional School for the last 11 years.
click for more