Public Safety Committee member Peter Breen talks about inspections as Chair Bryan Sapienza listens on Monday.
NORTH ADAMS, Mass. — After a hearing of complaints and responses about the North Adams Housing Authority, a meeting of the Public Safety Committee concluded Monday with calls for cooperation and communication.
"Every resident of the city of North Adams deserves safe, clean housing, and right now we're seeing a situation that it may not be true in all cases," said Chair Bryan Sapienza. "It's not going to be an easy answer. It's not going to take a couple of days. ... We need to work together as a community."
Members of the Housing Authority's Tenants Association have been attending City Council meetings for months to air concerns about security, safety, drugs, pests and what they say has been a lack of response by the housing agency's administration and Board of Commissioners. They have been championed by City Councilors Lillian Zavastky, liaison to the authority, and Virginia Riehl, and Jennifer Barbeau, a former councilor.
A grievance was filed against the longtime director, who abruptly resigned last month.
"A lot of things that have happened specifically over the last few months that has hindered the Housing Authority board specifically," said Commissioner Marie T. Harpin. "We do take everything that you say to us very seriously, and we take our job seriously. We know that we are affecting people's homes and safety, and that to me, honestly, as a board member, is very important."
In addition to the commissioners, the meeting was attended by Mayor Jennifer Macksey, Police Chief Mark Bailey, Building Inspector William Meranti, Deputy Fire Chief Robert Patenaude, Health Director Heather DeMarsico and other city employees.
The committee reviewed complaints about bedbugs and cockroaches, mold and air quality, and the agency's ability to remove residents who are breaking rules and laws.
In response to questions from committee member Peter Breen about pest inspections, interim Director Lisa Labonte and Meranti said complaints are investigated and that there is regular pest control actions.
Meranti said there seemed a miscommunication because Breen thought nothing was being done while inspection services is at 150 Ashland St., the high rise, frequently.
"That's not the truth. The truth is that a tenant makes a complaint. They make the complaint to the Housing Authority. The Housing Authority responds with their appropriate exterminator," he said. "There's an extended period of time that the problem exists, they reach out to the Health Department. ...
"I don't know that anybody can say that there's a complaint that nobody has responded to. That's just not something that happens."
Labonte said an exterminator comes in every Tuesday and sprays about a floor and half. But both said if a tenant won't let them into their units, there's nothing they can do. So if one unit is cleared, there may still be pests on the sides or above and below, plus the tenants have to follow through the plans to keep them from coming back.
"That is a tenant issue, not a city issue or a Housing Authority issue," Meranti said. "The Health Department has gone above and beyond to try to find relatives to help people that are having this problem over and over again ...
"They talk to the tenants themselves. There's a letter out there that the Housing Authority uses to give to the tenants on what to do to ... But when somebody next door says you can't come into my apartment, you start over."
Zavastky noted landlords can enter rental units for repairs or sanitation but DeMarsico and Labonte said they are not in a position to force their way into people's homes and would have to go to court.
"We can't make you open the door," said DeMarsico. "All we can do is give you the information and tell you that your best option is to allow them to do what they need to do in order to cure the problem. Unfortunately, you know, like Jen [Barbeau] said, your neighbors suffer if you can't allow them access."
The authority provided a communal event in October for residents for the hours needed to clear their units; some 22 residents refused to let the exterminators in said commissioners.
Some tenants at the meeting said they were wary of what was being sprayed, stating concerns about cancer and their pets, others that they didn't think the chemicals did anything or that the exterminator wasn't taking the time to do it properly. One man said he didn't have the capacity to clear out his cupboards for the work to proceed.
The conditions have left one resident unable to receive the medical and social services he's needed for nearly two months because his provider refuses to enter the high rise.
"The gentleman who's sitting in this room right now, who has been seven weeks without any services and lost his furniture three times and never refused entry into his apartment, which was every other week," said Barbeau. "What is his solution and what is his recourse? Because he has followed the rules and he can't get any health care."
Tenants Association President Corey Fortin raised the problem with the unsecured doors — people would block the emergency exit doors from closing and allow outsiders to enter at will. Labonte said the door alarms were being activated on Tuesday, though tenants pointed out this has been a problem for years.
Police Chief Mark Bailey said 150 Ashland St. generates the second highest incident and arrest reports and that 45 Spring St. is the fourth highest. Most calls are tenant disputes or substance abuse. It's easy to go through the camera system and see who's committing the violations — but it's the Housing Authority that has to hold the person accountable, he said.
"If you have a fear of losing ... your housing because you're being held accountable for your actions or what happens within your apartment, you're more likely going to be a good tenant," the chief said. "Most of the people that are there residing at these locations know the officers. They they talk to us. They know us by name. They wave to us if we're running by and doing our daily runs, so I feel like we have good communication skills with the tenants. There's just this disconnect of holding people accountable for their actions."
Labonte said evicting a tenant is an arduous process because it has to go to Housing Court. It took eight months to get one tenant out, she said.
"There are numerous people I send to court, who I send a 30-day notice for cause," she said. "I mean, they're not going to kick people out for using unless you're dealing out of your apartment or having so many people there. That's when it helps the eviction. But Housing Court is almost impossible to get somebody evicted."
Debra Chalk, who volunteers with the food pantry and makes deliveries to the high raise, said a dialogue is essential as the Tenants Association had a list of 27 issues and needs a response.
"Some of these things are five and 10 years not being resolved, and so the tenants find themselves frustrated. And even even tonight, I'm hearing frustration because it's like, 'oh, OK, the bed bugs are our fault,'" she said. "It would be it would be great to have some kind of a cooperative conversation about it because they have the right to a decent place to live."
Police Lt. Anthony Beverly said he strongly recommended documenting everything. Maybe the court wouldn't listen the first or the fourth time, but it would eventually, he said. Others advocated for more communication and mediation. Riehl said there were challenges but together, they could come up with solutions — maybe by seeing how other agencies have tackled them.
Sapienza said at the beginning of the meeting that his hope was facilitate cooperation between tenants, the authority and the city, "and get parties communicating."
Harpin said it wasn't the intention of the authority to point fingers but to resolve the issues. The commission will be opening the floor at its monthly meetings for tenant conversations, she said, and trying some other things to improve the situation.
A tenant from Greylock Apartments, who recounted how Mass Health had failed her unit that day for air quality, said she felt it was doable.
"I know it's tough. Tenants are screaming to be heard. Housing is screaming to be heard, and we need to figure out how to work together, build a plan, an actionable plan, to move forward without getting at each other's throat," she said. "Everybody wants the same thing. We just have to figure out how to do it together."
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.
Your Comments
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
No Comments
McCann Tech First Quarter Honor Roll
Staff Reports
McCann Tech First Quarter Honor Roll
Grade 12
High Honors
Carroll, Avery
Dupee, Tessa
Girard, Mia
Goldie, Shauna
Guiden, Riley
Kincaid-Chesbro, Cecilia
King, Danielle
Kruzel, Mark
Lovell, Isaac
Macpherson, Anna
Nowak, Landon
Patel, Dharmik
Pause, Addison
Peck, Honour
After a hearing of complaints and responses about the North Adams Housing Authority, a meeting of the Public Safety Committee concluded Monday with calls for cooperation and communication. click for more
Jaydee Reber ran for 128 yards and three touchdowns, and the Lee defense pitched a shutout until the final minute of a second half played entirely under running time. click for more
Lucca Hernandez headed home Silas Heck's cross from the right wing in the waning minutes of the first half to send the third-seeded Spartans to a 1-0 win over Westport in the Division 4 State Quarter-Finals. click for more
On a day set aside for recognizing local veterans, the city unveiled a new plaque that added or corrected the names of 169 who served during wartime.
click for more
The City Council on Tuesday accepted a fiscal 2025 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant in the amount of $14,231 for the construction of an evidence room.
click for more