A student-athlete on the Drury/Hoosac Valley Unified Basketball team participates in a game this season in a mobility device. The rules governing the sport statewide do not allow such devices to be used on the court in the same space as the other students during competition, and the Hoosac Valley School Committee is asking the state governing body to consider changing that.A student-athlete in a wheelchair participates in a Unified Basketball game at Mount Greylock this fall by utilizing a designated lane adjacent to the court.
Parent Jason Mendoca spoke to the inability of middle school students at St. Stan's to participate in sports at the high school. His daughter was denied a waiver to play on Hoosac's JV basketball team.
CHESHIRE, Mass. — Current state athletic regulations and proposed rule changes are raising concerns among parents and school officials about its potential impact on student participation in sports, particularly in rural communities like Berkshire County.
The Hoosac Valley School Committee discussed several Massachusetts Interscholastic Athletic Association (MIAA) policies Monday, including proposed varsity eligibility changes, mobility aids in Unified Sports and private-school students on public-school teams.
Athletic Director Jeff Puleri provided details on MIAA's proposed rule change "Student Eligibility: Middle School Students on Senior High Teams," which would restrict middle school students' eligibility to compete on varsity teams. MIAA is expected to vote on the item in December.
Under the proposed policy, middle school students would only be eligible to participate on junior varsity teams if they meet MIAA eligibility requirements. While, varsity competition would be limited to students in Grades 9 through 12, regardless of school structure.
While most of the district's younger athletes already participate at the JV level, the proposed restrictions could prevent students from participating in smaller sports that don't have JV, such as golf and track from competing altogether.
"There's still the ability to grab a waiver, but it's going to be under a little bit more extreme circumstances," Puleri said.
Current policy allows middle school students to represent a senior high school on its athletic teams when the high school includes those grades, and they are under the direct "jurisdiction" and "supervision" of the high school principal.
However, this potential rule change is only part of the concern with some parents seeking amendments to existing restrictions that they say prevent some students from participating in school sports.
School Committee member Erin Milne presented an open letter shared on Facebook by parent Jennifer Zuker.
Milne said she asked Zuker for permission to bring her concerns before the committee, which Zuker welcomed. However, Zuker wanted to make clear that she had no issues with the district's Unified basketball program.
"She found our Unified basketball coach and program extremely supportive, but they did run into an issue where another school put up an objection to her son playing in an active game, and it turns out that it is actually against current MIAA regulations for students who use mobility aids to play intermingled with other students," Milne said.
In her letter, Zuker said her son, Elliott, was thrilled to be part of the Unified Basketball team as it gave him the opportunity to practice, play, contribute to his team, and experience the excitement of being part of something with his school.
However, when they faced off against another school on Oct. 14, he was not allowed to play on the court because of liability concerns, she said.
"Instead, the school offered to designate an aisle for him with cones and a separate hoop, or to clear the court so he could shoot … although these options were offered with good intentions, they were not meaningful participation in the game Elliott became used to. He felt excluded and patronized, and left before the game began," Zuker said.
The current Unified Basketball rules, developed by the MIAA and Special Olympics, prohibit students from using wheelchairs and other mobility devices during games.
Students in wheelchairs can and do participate in Unified games in the Berkshire County League, in special lanes on the side of the court with adaptive baskets.
Zuker wrote in her Facebook post that student-athletes with mobility devices are directed toward skills competitions and adaptive sports, but the teams available are about an hour away and include athletes of all ages because there are not enough players for separate youth and adult teams.
While these programs are valuable, they cannot replace the opportunity to represent your school and play alongside their peers, she said.
This season, Zuker said she watched students on the school's Unified basketball team exhibit a range of abilities, with some needing guidance around the court and others demonstrating "impressive basketball skills."
"I watched Elliot carefully navigate around other players. His teammates passed him the ball and sometimes gave him extra space near the baskets. They found ways to play together and those moments gave Elliot a chance to contribute while giving his teammates the opportunity to support one another," she said.
"I also saw players learning and developing their understanding of basketball as the season progressed. We cheered every time either team scored, and often cheered loudest when someone showed perseverance and eventually made a shot.
"That is part of what makes Unified Basketball so special. It is about more than perfect basketball skills. It's about teamwork, belonging, respect, and the opportunity to participate."
Given that the regulations are overseen by the MIAA, the district does not have the authority to make changes. However, Milne proposed a resolution to send to MIAA and show committee members' support for the change. The committee approved this resolution.
"It's non-binding, but it just kind of shows our support for a more inclusive model that specifically asks them instead of having a blanket banning of everyone who uses mobility aids to try to see if accommodations could be made for specific individuals in specific cases where it can be done safely," Milne said.
The committee also discussed existing MIAA regulations that have prevented some private middle school students from participating on public high school athletic teams, even when they live within the district.
Berkshire County has three Catholic schools that go to Grade 8, St. Stanislaus Kostka School in Adams, Saint Agnes Academy in Dalton, and St. Mary's in Lee, School Committee Chair Fred Lora said.
Under MIAA regulations, cooperative athletic agreements are limited to member schools, preventing private schools such as these from establishing joint athletic programs with their local public high schools.
The policy also requires cooperative teams to be necessary to sustain an existing program or create a new one because of insufficient participation, rather than simply allowing individual students to join another school's team.
MIAA regulations also require middle-level waivers to meet specific eligibility criteria, including attending a school with a direct pathway to the receiving high school.
This is even the case for students at St. Stan's who would otherwise attend Hoosac Valley if enrolled in public school, said Jason Mendonca, whose daughter was unable to join the district's junior varsity basketball team after her local youth team lost too many players to continue.
Mendonca said the waiver was denied because Hoosac Valley was not considered his daughter's designated "pathway" school, despite the family living in Cheshire, where she would otherwise be eligible to attend the district's public high school.
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.
Your Comments
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
No Comments
Adams to Evaluate Restructure of Greylock Glen Operations
By Sabrina DammsiBerkshires Staff
ADAMS, Mass. — The Board of Selectmen are planning to evaluate the Greylock Glen Outdoor Center following the departure of Executive Director Daniel Doyle.
Doyle submitted his two-week notice at the beginning of the month after a year in the post. His last day was Friday.
The board will hold a workshop meeting on Wednesday, Dec. 9, at 6 p.m. to consider the facility's future management structure.
Town Administrator Nicholas Caccamo said on Wednesday night that one of the likely considerations is how the town views the outdoor center within its operating budget.
The town's budget currently covers costs for the glen, though the hope for years has been to make the outdoor center financially independent.
The meeting will also likely consider the broader history of the Greylock Glen project and how the outdoor center fits into the town's long-term plans, Caccamo said.
In the long run, the town "obviously" will need someone to oversee the facility's operations, but the job description will be determined based on Greylock Glen's current needs, the town administrator said.
Current state athletic regulations and proposed rule changes are raising concerns among local parents and school officials about its potential impact on student participation in sports, particularly in rural communities like Berkshire County. click for more
The project's estimated cost had increased from $2.2 million to $3.9 million, prompting the town to request a budget amendment, an extension of the project timeline and approval of its final design to proceed with bidding.
click for more
Jaydee Reber ran for 128 yards and three touchdowns, and the Lee defense pitched a shutout until the final minute of a second half played entirely under running time. click for more
Lucca Hernandez headed home Silas Heck's cross from the right wing in the waning minutes of the first half to send the third-seeded Spartans to a 1-0 win over Westport in the Division 4 State Quarter-Finals. click for more
Hoosac Valley Middle and High School students lined the hallways with handmade signs and artwork on Monday as they welcomed local veterans with applause, high-fives, and words of appreciation during the annual Veterans Day celebration. click for more