Williamstown Planning Board Narrows Focus for 2027 Bylaw Proposals
WILLIAMSTOWN, Mass. — The Planning Board last week settled on at least three warrant articles it wants to bring to town meeting in May 2027.
It plans to use the next few months to finalize the details of exactly what it proposes to plan to the town's legislative body.
"There are three warrant articles: one for undersized lots for the Seasonal Communities designation, one for common driveways and one I'm calling an
omnibus or cleanup article to change 'Selectmen' to 'Select Board' and other things," Chair Kenneth Kuttner said at the outset of the board's November meeting.
The largest of the three proposals grows out of a review of the town's zoning bylaw by consultants at Northampton planning firm Dodson and Flinker.
One of the things the consultant found is that while the town replaced the term "Board of Selectmen" with "Select Board" in the town charter, the zoning bylaw still has vestigial references to the former term.
Another change would create a citation to the "low-impact development" design practices that the board plans to include in the
subdivision control bylaw, which, unlike the zoning bylaw, is a creation of the board and does not go through the town meeting process.
At their Nov. 10 meeting, the planners also talked about a couple of updates proposed by Dodson and Flinker that may or may not make it into the final bylaw amendment draft.
One is a suggestion that the town revise its definition of a nonresidential street, currently defined in the bylaw as, "a street that serves as access for land in a nonresidential district."
At the November meeting, the Planners generally agreed that it is unlikely to be used in a town with so little land in its nonresidential districts.
"The idea of nonresidential has been muddled over the last few years," town planner Andrew Groff noted. "Because all those districts, except Limited Industrial, allow multi-family [housing]. They allow mixed use. So are they non-residential? They're kind of in-between.
"The industrial zone, which is essentially limited to the Steinerfilm lot, the town garage and the sewer plant, that's the only one."
Kuttner proposed that since there are no other references to non-residential streets in the code other than the definition, the definition simply be removed, a solution with which the rest of the board appeared to agree.
There are other bylaw proposals that are going to take more discussion among the board before it is ready to present for public hearings leading up to town meeting.
Two are related to last spring's adoption of the commonwealth's Seasonal Communities designation by town meeting.
The program, which already has benefited Williamstown in terms of an $86,144
grant to support affordable housing, requires that towns modify their bylaws to allow "tiny homes" and the development of undersized lots in residential districts to create year-round housing.
Groff told the board that he is seeking clarification from state officials on whether the town needs to do anything on the tiny homes front because the current bylaw does not set a minimum size for homes. It is possible that state regulators will want to see tiny homes called out as a specific class in the bylaw, but that remains an unknown.
As for the undersized lot requirement, the board discussed whether it wants to follow the example of early adopters of the Seasonal Communities program and require that homes created on those lots have an affordability component by means of a deed restriction tying the property's value to some percentage of the Area Median Income.
The planners spent some time at the November meeting discussing what percentage of AMI it might choose, kicking around numbers ranging from 100 percent to 250 percent.
"The lower the percentage of AMI, the fewer number of applicants there will be and the harder it will be to sell that lot," Roger Lawrence said. "And that will effectively cap the price that can be charged for that lot. It will essentially bring down the sale of that land by some increment. I don't know how much."
The conversation led to an explanation by Groff of why affordable housing does not get built without public or private subsidies.
"Habitat for Humanity right now is building homes for roughly about $300 per square foot with free labor," Groff said. "If I look at our building permit database, being generous it's $400 to $450 at the lower end up to people with very refined tastes and high-end finishes up to $500 to $600.
"If you look at, say, a 1,600 square foot house, something you'd think of as a small, starter home, even at $450, you're looking at over $700,000 to build it."
Groff said that grants from the Seasonal Communities program are one potential avenue to enable construction of affordable – or attainable – housing. But he cautioned that systemic pressure on housing costs is bigger than that.
"[The Seasonal Communities program] is just a kernel now," he said. "It's going to take an enormous amount of money to solve this problem. We can't just throw money at it from the state level. That's just going to make the cost of construction go even higher. A whole bunch of other things need to happen.
"This is a problem that impacts not just Williamstown. It impacts everyone. It impacts our neighboring communities that have much older housing stock. This cost of construction problem impacts our neighbors the most."
In the short term, town meeting will need to do something to enable development on undersized lots and, perhaps, address tiny homes in the next two years if the town wants to stay retain its Seasonal Communities designation.
The Planning Board also wants town meeting this spring to consider legislation that would allow for the use of common driveways that would serve up to three primary residences on a single building lot.
The board last pitched that idea in 2020, when a bylaw proposal was ultimately withdrawn from the floor – actually, field – of the
annual town meeting.
Kuttlner noted that a proposed bylaw generated by Dodson and Flinker is very much the same as the 2020 proposal and that, if the town adopted a common driveway bylaw, it would allow for the kind of development envisioned by its "Minor Lane" subdivision designation, a development pattern that has not been employed since it was added to the books.
The board at its November meeting discussed the number of units that could be accessed off a common driveway and the fact that a common driveway bylaw would be more usable if it addressed the frontage requirements for the property it serves.
"I've always interpreted our bylaw as allowing this now," Groff said. "[A common driveway is] just not covered by zoning. It's covered by legal agreements. Like, right now, if you've got 500 feet of frontage and you want to set up a bunch of flag lots, that's between you and your neighbors."
The frontage requirement for a single-family home in the General Residence District is 66 feet, so three homes on the site served by a common driveway would need nearly 200 feet of frontage.
The planners discussed whether there was some way to reduce the frontage requirement for sites where a common driveway is used.
Lawrence asked whether the driveway itself could create frontage for the buildings on the lot, but Kuttner answered that what he was suggesting would be a subdivision.
"Correct, which is why I think no one ever used Minor Lane, because it was a subdivision permit plus a special permit, which simply creates too many points of veto by appeal," Groff said. "There are so many opportunities for parties of interest – i.e., your neighbors – to file an appeal to gum up the works that it makes it uneconomical."
The board decided to have Kuttner and Groff explore how the frontage issue could be addressed in a common driveway proposal.
"There are 350 other communities [in Massachusetts]," Groff said. "Someone has done something creative with common driveways."
The board also at the Nov. 10 meeting continued its discussion on a bylaw amendment proposal that may or may not be ready for the 2027 town meeting. Cory Campbell led a conversation about the mixed-use, form-based zoning proposal that he has been advocating for since he joined the board.
The board is weighing whether it could roll out the zoning change in one or two potential overlay districts – the east end of Main Street (Route 2) or the north end of Cole Avenue – as a test case to see if they can win approval and, potentially, spur development of commercial and residential properties.
Tags: bylaws,