Friends of St. Mary's Forms To Save Endangered Pittsfield Church

By Joe DurwinPittsfield Correspondent
Print Story | Email Story
An ad hoc committee of concerned citizens has formed to facilitate a future for St. Mary's Church.

PITTSFIELD, Mass. — A group of former parishioners and other concerned residents have formed an ad hoc committee aimed at encouraging the reuse of the former St. Mary the Morningstar Church, a Tyler Street landmark whose fate has become uncertain in recent weeks.

"The committee's hope is to provide information and assistance to all interested parties who would like to take an active role in finding a suitable re-purpose for St. Mary's Church," according to a statement released by the new group.

The committee first saw its formation immediately after the surprise announcement by Dunkin' Donuts developer Cafua Management that it wishes to purchase and donate that structure in exchange for community support for its revised plan to erect a drive through eatery on the site of the former convent and rectory buildings at that site.

It had initially proposed a controversial plan to demolish the church property.

The Friends group has been quietly meeting to discuss and define what role this informal affinity group can have in finding a solution to the redevelopment of the church.

"I don't know what inspired Cafua to say that they would donate the church to the city, but initially we were all really excited about that," said committee spokeswoman Darcie Sosa at a community meeting on historic preservation on Wednesday. "We know that they have offered to donate it to the city, which we realize isn't necessarily the best opportunity to repurpose it, and that isn't something that should be put on taxpayers."

So far the committee consists of 10 members, three of whom are former city councilors — its president, Bill Barry, and Peter Marchetti and Michael Ward — as well as a variety of Morningside neighborhood residents and persons with past associations to the historic church.



According to Barry, attorneys representing Cafua say they are willing to consider proposals that would see the church redeveloped by a third party company or non-profit, provided that entity can demonstrate a solid plan and at least $150,000 in funds to take on the formidable task.  

In addition to the inherent costs of repurposing and getting the building up to code for some other use, any potential new owner will face substantial repair work to the church, which has degraded structurally in the six years that it has been vacant and not maintained.

"We're really going to try to work with potential developers, with the Diocese of Springfield, and with Cafua, city elected officials and anyone in the community that has ideas," said Sosa.

In order to help assist this process, the group has obtained extensive blueprints of the 73-year-old church building, as well as the older adjacent St. Mary's School building, formerly the Tyler Street Theatre.

Mayor Daniel Bianchi reacted favorably to the announcement of the new ad hoc committee, encouraging others with an interest in preserving the church to contact them.

"I would love to hear more about the ideas you have, and I would love to see what we might possibly do," Bianchi told them. "If there are developers or others who might have an idea, please reach out to them."

 

St. Marys Full Set Architecture Drawings

 

ST Mary School 1916

 


Tags: ad hoc committee,   church reuse,   historical building,   neighborhood,   

If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.

Friday Front Porch Feature: This Luxury Home Has Plenty of Amenities

By Breanna SteeleiBerkshires Staff

LENOX, Mass. — Are you looking for a big house to enjoy your days with a big movie theater, a sauna, and more? Then this is the house for you.

Built in 2004, this seven-bedroom, and nine-bathroom home is 7,073 square feet on more than an acre. The home comes with an elevator to the lower level to access a theater, sauna, gym, wine cellar, massage room, and its very own soda fountain. 

The home also has a guest house with a saltwater pool. A multi-car garage greets you with heated floors.

The this home is listed for $4,950,000 and is located in the 125-acre, gated Pinecroft compound.

We spoke to Leslie Chesloff, the listing agent with William Pitt Sotheby's.

What do you think makes this property stand out in the current market?

Chesloff: This gated Berkshire stone estate truly redefines luxury living in the Berkshires. What sets it apart is the rare combination of resort-style amenities and complete privacy. The property offers Canyon Ranch-level wellness living with a full spa experience at home — including a sauna, massage room, and gym — plus an eight-seat hi-def theater with wine cellar for entertaining. The heated, gunite saltwater pool and spa are complemented by a fully equipped pool house with a guest suite and complete kitchen, perfect for extended family or guests.

What was your first impression when you walked into the home?

The moment you step inside, you're struck by the quality and craftsmanship — those 300-year-old reclaimed timber floors set an immediate tone of authenticity and warmth. The scale is impressive but never overwhelming; this is a home designed for gracious living, not just show. The natural light, cathedral ceilings, and thoughtful flow between spaces create an inviting atmosphere that balances grandeur with genuine comfort.

How would you describe the feel or atmosphere of this home?

This home feels like a private wellness retreat meets sophisticated family estate. There's a serene, spa-like quality throughout — enhanced by features like the sauna, steam shower, and massage room — but it never feels clinical or cold. The Berkshire stone exterior and reclaimed timber floors ground the home in a sense of place and permanence. It's designed for people who appreciate the finer things but want to actually live well — whether that's screening a film in the eight-seat theater with wine from your own cellar, hosting poolside gatherings, or simply unwinding in your own spa sanctuary.

What kind of buyer would this home be ideal for?

This is perfect for the discerning buyer who values wellness, privacy, and culture in equal measure. I envision someone who spends their days hiking or exploring the Berkshires, then comes home to unwind in the sauna or pool. They might entertain guests in the theater wine room, host multi-generational gatherings with family staying in the pool house guest suite (which has a full kitchen), and appreciate being minutes from Tanglewood, world-class dining, and Berkshire arts.

This could be an executive looking for a primary residence with work-from-home flexibility (there's an office/bedroom suite), a wellness-focused family, or empty nesters who want to host adult children and grandchildren in style and comfort.

What would you say to a buyer trying to imagine their life in this space?

Picture Saturday morning: you're sipping coffee on the terrace overlooking your heated saltwater pool, planning a day at Tanglewood. Your guests are making breakfast in the pool house kitchen — they have their own private retreat but are steps away when you're ready to gather. Evening arrives, and you screen a favorite film in your eight-seat theater, selecting a perfect bottle from your wine cellar. This isn't just a home; it's a lifestyle that brings resort-level wellness, entertainment, and hospitality to your doorstep — all within a secure, maintenance-free compound where nature meets luxury.

Are there any standout design features or recent renovations?

Absolutely. The home includes an elevator for multilevel accessibility, which is both practical and forward-thinking. The lower level is exceptionally well-conceived — a true entertainment and wellness wing featuring the eight-seat hi-def theater, wine cellar, sauna, gym, massage room, and even a charming soda fountain. The gourmet kitchen has been recently updated, customized wet bar, while outdoor living is elevated with the heated gunite saltwater pool/spa, firepit, and that incredible pool house with guest suite and full kitchen. Also, new HVAC system and heated driveway.

Thoughtful details like cedar closets, steam showers, central vacuum, and backup generator show this home was built to the highest standards.

You can find out more about this house on its listing here.

*Front Porch Feature brings you an exclusive to some of the houses listed on our real estate page every week. Here we take a bit of a deeper dive into a certain house for sale and ask questions so you don't have to.

View Full Story

More Pittsfield Stories