Update June 12: Navom was reportedly arrested in Litchfield, N.H., and released on personal recognizance last week; McLenithan was set to be arraigned on Monday morning. 

 

NORTH ADAMS, Mass. — The owner of the apartment building that burned down on May 17 is expected to be charged with arson and conspiracy along with an alleged accomplice.

 

Police say Brandon Navom, 42, of State Road hired 19-year-old Gabriel McLenithan, a former tenant, to torch the condemned building that was insured for $1.2 million. 

 

Two witnesses, including a woman who had had a relationship with McLenithan, say McLenithan had told them he started the fire for a $10,000 payment and an apartment outside the area, according to the arrest warrant. 

 

 

Firefighters responded to 28 Morgan Ave. around 11 p.m. on May 17 to find the 1880-circa building fully engulfed. Flames could be seen throughout the downtown. Residents at a nearby State Street house were evacuated for several hours. 

 

Fire officials and the State Fire Marshal's Office had deemed the blaze "suspicious."

 

Navom purchased the eight-apartment building in January 2022 for $100,000. At the time of the fire, no one was living there. The 1880 building had been condemned as being uninhabitable and structurally unsafe. 

 

According to the report filed with the warrant by Detective Tyler Drewnowski, Navom the following morning suggested that an evicted tenant or possibly a squatter might be responsible. He declined on the advice of his attorney to state where he had been the prior day following a Zoom meeting with the Board of Health over another building he had an interest in. He told the detective he was unsure if the Morgan Avenue building was insured, according to the report. 

 

Investigators say they learned Navom had taken out a $300,000 mortgage on the property and an insurance policy for $1.2 million through Hartford Insurance Co.

 

McLenithan's former girlfriend, with whom he is having a child, contacted police and later provided them with text messages from McLenithan in which he says he is "doing something to make it so we have money to raise our child." In the text messages, there's a reference to $10,000 and an offer to buy her a car. He insists she call him and during that conversation, and she told police that he said the business he was referring to was burning the building.

 

Another witness told police that McLenithan had been bragging about starting the fire and had told her he would bail out his friend (her ex-boyfriend) who was currently being held. According to this witness, Navom had picked up McLenithan from where he was living in Webster and then drove him back after the fire. 

 

McLenithan had apparently lived for some time at Navom's apartment building at 680 State Road including as Navom's roommate there. A witness says McLenithan was at Navom's house the day of the fire.