Local Blogger Complies With Court Order to Remove Nilan Content

By Joe DurwinPittsfield Correspondent
Print Story | Email Story
PITTSFIELD, Mass. — Stockbridge resident and blogger on local affairs Daniel Valenti has complied with a judge's order to remove all blog posts making reference to Meridith Nilan, who was spared penalty earlier this month in a hit-and-run motor vehicle incident that nearly took the life of Pittsfield resident Peter Moore. 

In total, Valenti says he removed about 76 posts from his blog PlanetValenti.com

"We have removed all posts that reference the Plaintiff, her father, and references to the victim of the Dec. 8, 2011 incident," said Valenti on his blog. "We went beyond what the court asked to demonstrate our good faith in dealing with the order."

Valenti says he received the one-page court order Wednesday night, and while the blogger, who has written in the past for The Berkshire Eagle, Pittsfield Gazette and other publications, says there are First Amendment issues with the court's decision, he will abide by it.

On Wednesday, Valenti told iBerkshires via email that he had yet to see the judge's decision and he would have to see that before determining his next course of action.

"I found out about it while reading the comments on my blog, ironically," Valenti said. "I've never had any contact with Ms. Nilan nor do I intend that. I will also add that this case brings up an interesting First Amendment discussion."

The Nilan/Moore motor vehicle incident had comprised the top or primary story on the blog for several months earlier this year, and has been a continued point of interest for its group of regular commenters. According to statistics obtained from various site traffic tracking services, searches for information about Meredith Nilan have accounted for just over 8 percent of the blog's total traffic in recent months.

PlanetValenti.com was launched in September 2010, and has several times become a center of controversy and accusations of inaccurate reporting. The self-proclaimed "Voice of the Little Guy" has also broken several local stories. The domain PlanetValenti.com is registered as owned by Troy Book Makers, of Troy, N.Y., with Susan Novotny listed as the contact person. Novotny is co-owner of Troy Book Makers and owner of The Stuyvesant Plaza Book House in Albany, N.Y.

Valenti has frequently maintained the site attracts many thousands of readers, though he has several times declined requests to provide statistics backing this claim. In December 2011, Valenti claimed the site was ranked 2,397,097 of all world websites, according to Alexa.com traffic rankings.  As of today, however, Alexa lists the site as ranked 3,741,979. Other site-traffic measurement services also rate it as being in the high 3 millions (the lower the ranking, the higher the traffic), depending on how recent their gathered data.

More detailed statistical estimates obtained from another online traffic index, SpySiteTraffic.com, indicate that the site receives an average of 15 readers per day, with a monthly average of about 451 readers, but they do tend stay longer than average, at about 8 minutes on the site.  As compared to other online sites devoted to local news, PV.com appears to garner just a little under a 10th the readers of iBerkshires, or about 3 percent that of BerkshireEagle.com.

Editor's note: The hit-and-run charge was dismissed. We have corrected the description based on the court ruling.

Tags: blogger,   columnist,   court order,   Nilan,   planetvalenti.com,   

If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.

Pittsfield Families Frustrated Over Unreleased PHS Report, Herberg Slur Incident

By Brittany PolitoiBerkshires Staff

PITTSFIELD, Mass. — Parents are expressing their frustration with hate speech, bullying, and staff misconduct, which they said happens in Pittsfield schools. 

Community members and some elected officials have consistently advocated for the release of the redacted Pittsfield High School investigation report, and a teacher being placed on leave for allegedly repeating racist and homophobic slurs sparked a community conversation about how Pittsfield Public Schools can address injustices. 

The district's human resources director detailed the investigation processes during last week's School Committee meeting.

"People are angry. They feel like when they spoke up about Morningside School, it was closed anyway. They feel like they speak up about the PHS report, and that's just kind of getting shoved under the rug," resident Brenda Coddington said during public comment.

"I mean, when do people who actually voted for all of you, by the way, when does their voice and opinion count and matter? Because you can sit up here all day long and say that it does, but your actions, or rather lack of action, speak volumes."

Last month, School Committee member Ciara Batory demanded a date for the 2025 report's release to the public.

Three administrators and two teachers, past and present, were investigated by Bulkley Richardson and Gelinas LLP for a range of allegations that surfaced or re-surfaced at the end of 2024 after Pittsfield High's former dean of students was arrested and charged by the U.S. Attorney's Office for allegedly conspiring to traffic large quantities of cocaine in Western Massachusetts.

Executive summaries were released that concluded the claims of inappropriate conduct between teachers and students were "unsupported." Ward 7 Councilor Katherine Moody countered one of the unsupported determinations, writing on Facebook last week that she knows one person can conclude with confidence and a court case that pictures of the staff member's genitalia was sent to minors. 

"During this investigation, we sought to determine the validity of allegations about PHS Administrator #2 sharing a photograph of female genitalia with PHS students on her Snapchat account," the final executive summary reads. 

View Full Story

More Pittsfield Stories