WILLIAMSTOWN, Mass. — Without an actionable measure to vote, the Mount Greylock School Committee on Thursday spent nearly an hour talking about the athletic field decision that will be left to the next iteration of the panel.
And three members blocked a proposal to collect data to help inform that decision.
The committee learned Thursday that its architects had not yet given the district a price for drafting new detailed design documents needed for a request for proposals to do upgrades to Mount Greylock's athletic fields.
Those same architects also advised the committee not to review potential "value engineering" deductions from the project or follow a proposal to put out simultaneous RFPs for a synthetic turf field and a natural grass field.
That "two-RFP" approach would have been one way to honor a September 2019 decision by the School Committee to get hard numbers on both a grass and a synthetic field before deciding which, if any, to install on the Cold Spring Road campus.
But it might not have been in the district's best interest, the committee was told.
"Perkins-Eastman's professional take was paying double for preparation for two of everything used for bid documents is probably a waste of money as far as they're concerned," Business Manager Joe Bergeron said. "You also open yourself up to bid protest around the selection being a political, rather than an objective, process. So once the bids came in, there would be political and subjective things going on about who won the contract. That would create some problems for the committee and the district.
"[Dueling RFPs] would also decrease the quality of the bids submitted because people's attention and tying up their time in the process in bidding as well as their financial commitment would not be worth it to them."
The advice from the architects was that the School Committee should decide between grass and artificial turf first and then put the project "on the street."
Bergeron is serving as the district's point person to communicate with the architects during the development of an RFP. On Oct. 16, the School Committee voted, 4-2, to direct him to pursue an RFP that: addresses needed improvements to address deficiencies under the Americans with Disabilities Act and Title IX; installs an artificial turf field with an environmentally friendly, renewable infill rather than the standard crumb rubber; and lists a track as an "add alternate."
Last fall, the district sent out an RFP with largely the same parameters, except listing an environmentally friendly infill as an add alternate, like the track. That time around, the district got three bids with base bids ranging from $2.85 million to $2.98 million. The bids on the track came in between $549,000 and $879,000. The bids on the alternate for a biodegradeable infill came in from $64,500 to $153,000.
The committee left its Oct. 16 meeting anticipating it would be able to take the next step on Thursday and approve the expenditure to draw up the detailed design documents.
After it became apparent that would not happen — and with the idea of a grass field RFP off the table — Carolyn Greene suggested that the committee take advantage of a lull in the process to survey the community to gauge its level of support for installing a synthetic field.
Christina Conry agreed.
"We haven't done a climate survey around the field or the track or anything in that regard," Conry said. "What if we find out 95 percent of the community and families and students want an artificial turf field? That's going to give us direction. What if we find out, on the other side of the fence, that 95 percent of the community doesn't want an artificial turf field at all?
"We could get some valuable feedback."
Al Terranova argued against the idea of asking members of the community to weigh in on the issue — first when Greene brought up the idea in an afternoon meeting of the committee's Finance Subcommittee and again later during the full committee meeting.
"If we're going to do that, let's do away with elected officials," Terranova said. "Let's have a survey on what to do with the police chief and town manager in Williamstown. Let's do a survey on what to do with the streetlights in Williamstown. Let's do a survey to decide what to do with the marijuana thing. We are elected to make decisions. We're not elected to take a survey."
One of Terranova's examples, the "marijuana thing," was an apparent reference to Williamstown's current debate about a bylaw governing production of cannabis in town. That issue only could be resolved through a "survey," of sorts, as it would require a two-thirds vote at town meeting.
Alison Carter also dismissed the idea of a survey on the synthetic vs. grass field question, questioning whether survey participants would be as well informed as School Committee members.
"I'm totally for transparency and doing a temperature check of the community, but I really worry about how we could structure a survey to make sure people who are responding are not doing so based on incorrect information," Carter said. "If we were to do this now, there's a real danger of that happening.
"I'm worried that people are talking to their friends and raising concerns, and if you don't know any better, [artificial turf] sounds horrible and scary."
Steven Miller joined Carter and Terranova in opposing the idea of a survey.
"As Carrie [Greene] has said, if playability is the number one issue, this is a no-brainer," Miller said. "We have the athletic director stating that synthetic turf meets our need and grass does not. We should have a meeting next week and vote on the documents then."
Miller twice suggested a special meeting for next week to give the School Committee one more chance before the Nov. 3 election to approve the appropriation to draw up the new detailed design documents.
Neither Jamie Art, Carter nor Terranova are running for re-election; Greene is being challenged in her bid to stay on the committee. The School Committee meets Wednesday with the select boards from Lanesborough and Williamstown to fill an unexpired term due to a resignation. That means the seven-person committee is guaranteed to have at least four — and possibly five — new members when it convenes after Election Day.
"To the next committee, I'd be discouraged if you override the work of a committee working on the issue for 4 1/2 years," Terranova said during the Finance Subcommittee meeting.
Art cautioned his colleagues against prioritizing a synthetic playing field over preserving the proceeds of a $5 million capital gift for future extraordinary maintenance needs at the middle/high school given the fact that the Lanesborough Board of Selectmen, Williamstown Select Board and Williamstown Finance Committee each have recommended the latter path.
"Of far more value than the amount of money in the capital gift is this district's public good will and trust," Art said. "This process will either inspire confidence or erode confidence.
"Make sure that the decision's not just what the School Committee thinks is best for the district, but it is after a process that the public feels like makes sense to them. I don't think we're there yet. If we don't do that as a district … we might end up with a really expensive amenity. It may be lovely, and the towns might resent it.
"At that point, you have given the other independent bodies that we need to work well with a bat that they can beat up the School Committee with in budget fights year after year after year after year.
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.
Your Comments
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
Some of this sounds like a White House press conference. If there was no public input, we'd be stuck with carcinogenic rubber crumb field. The only research about BrockFILL that you can find on the Internet is that of its manufacturer. Seems like we are flying blind here. There also may be a trend away from artificial surface for fewer athlete injuries. Also keep in mind that ALL students will use these fields, not just athletes. Will more usage lead to a shorter shelf life?
Williams Seeking Town Approval for New Indoor Practice Facility
By Stephen DravisiBerkshires Staff
WILLIAMSTOWN, Mass. — The Planning Board last week gave Williams College the first approval it needs to build a 55,000-square foot indoor athletic facility on the north side of its campus.
Over the strenuous objection of a Southworth Street resident, the board found that the college's plan for a "multipurpose recreation center" or MRC off Stetson Road has adequate on-site parking to accommodate its use as an indoor practice facility to replace Towne Field House, which has been out of commission since last spring and was demolished this winter.
The college plans a pre-engineered metal that includes a 200-meter track ringing several tennis courts, storage for teams, restrooms, showers and a training room. The athletic surface also would be used as winter practice space for the school's softball and baseball teams, who, like tennis and indoor track, used to use the field house off Latham Street.
Since the planned structure is in the watershed of Eph's Pond, the college will be before the Conservation Commission with the project.
It also will be before the Zoning Board of Appeals, on Thursday, for a Development Plan Review and relief from the town bylaw limiting buildings to 35 feet in height. The new structure is designed to have a maximum height of 53 1/2 feet and an average roof height of 47 feet.
The additional height is needed for two reasons: to meet the NCAA requirement for clearance above center court on a competitive tennis surface (35 feet) and to include, on one side, a climbing wall, an element also lost when Towne Field House was razed.
The Planning Board had a few issues to resolve at its March 12 meeting. The most heavily discussed involved the parking determination for a use not listed in the town's zoning bylaws and a decision on whether access from town roads to the building site in the middle of Williams' campus was "functionally equivalent" to the access that would be required under the town's subdivision rules and regulations.
Zimmermann comes to the Milne Public Library from Wisconsin with over eight years of management experience in library services, most recently as the Executive Director of the Racine Public Library.
click for more
Manary talked to the Fin Comm about the Massachusetts Public Library Construction Program, which, he said, funds anywhere from 50 to 75 percent of construction costs.
click for more
Taylor Garabedian scored a team-high 22 points and grabbed five rebounds, and Abby Scialabba scored 16 points for the ‘Canes, who got 16 points, nine rebounds and four assists from Ashlyn Lesure. click for more
On Saturday afternoon at Lowell’s Tsongas Center, the Hurricanes will take aim at Division 5 State Championships in girls and boys basketball. click for more
There are only two known copies of the flag in existence: one at the State House and one in the meeting room on the first floor at Town Hall.
click for more